Bundestag

The Bundestag (German pronunciation: [ˈbʊndəstaːk], "Federal Diet") is the German federal parliament. It is the only body that is directly elected by the German people on the Federal level. It can be compared to the lower house similar to the United States House of Representatives or the House of Commons of the United Kingdom. The Bundestag was established by Title III[lower-alpha 2] of the Basic Law for the Federal Republic of Germany (German: Grundgesetz) in 1949 as one of the legislative bodies of Germany and thus it is the historical successor to the earlier Reichstag.

German Federal Diet

Deutscher Bundestag
19th Bundestag
History
Established1949
Preceded byReichstag (Nazi Germany) 1933–1945
Volkskammer (East Germany) 1949–1990
Leadership
Wolfgang Schäuble, CDU
since 24 October 2017
Thomas Oppermann, SPD
since 24 October 2017
Hans-Peter Friedrich, CSU
since 24 October 2017
Wolfgang Kubicki, FDP
since 24 October 2017
Petra Pau, The Left
since 7 April 2006
Claudia Roth, Alliance 90/The Greens
since 22 October 2013
Structure
Seats709
[1][2]
Political groups
Government (398)
  •      Union (246)
    •      CDU (200)
    •      CSU (46)
  •      SPD (152)

Opposition (311)

Elections
Mixed-member proportional representation (MMP)
Last election
24 September 2017
Next election
On or before 24 October 2021
Meeting place
Reichstag
Mitte, Berlin, Germany
Website
bundestag.de
This article is part of a series on the
politics and government of
Germany
Southeastern corner of Bundestag.

The Members of the Bundestag are representatives of the German people as a whole and are not bound by any orders or instructions and are only held accountable by their electorate.[lower-alpha 3] The minimum legal number of members of the Bundestag (German: Mitglieder des Bundestages) is 598;[lower-alpha 4] however due to the system of overhang and equalisation seats the current 19th Bundestag has a total of 709 members, making it the largest Bundestag to date.

The Bundestag is elected every four years by German citizens[lower-alpha 5] over the age of 18.[lower-alpha 6] Elections use a mixed-member proportional representation system which combines first-past-the-post elected seats with a proportional party list. An early election is only possible in the cases outlined in Articles 63 and 68 of the Grundgesetz.

The Bundestag has several functions. Together with the Bundesrat, the Bundestag makes up the legislative branch of the Federal Government. The individual states (Bundesländer) of Germany participate through the Bundesrat in legislative process similar to an upper house in a bicameral parliament, however the Grundgesetz[3] considers the Bundestag and Bundesrat to be separate from each other (in contrast, the US Constitution states that the House of Representatives and the Senate make up Congress as a single unified legislative body. This is not the case with the Bundestag and Bundesrat). The Bundestag and Bundesrat nevertheless work together in the lawmaking procedure on the federal level. The Bundestag also elects the Executive and is responsible for executive oversight. The Bundestag also sets the Federal Budget.

Since 1999, it has met in the Reichstag in Berlin.[4] The Bundestag also operates in multiple new government buildings in Berlin and has its own police force (Bundestagspolizei). The current President of the Bundestag since 2017 is Wolfgang Schäuble of the CDU. The 19th Bundestag has five Vice Presidents.

History

Bundestag translates accurately as "League Council", literally meaning "bound day". "Tag" (day), short for "Tagung" (meeting for a day), came to mean "meeting in conference" — another example being Reichstag — because a council gathering would happen on a given day of the week, month, or year.[5]

With the dissolution of the German Confederation in 1866 and the founding of the German Empire (Deutsches Reich) in 1871, the Reichstag was established as the German parliament in Berlin, which was the capital of the then Kingdom of Prussia (the largest and most influential state in both the Confederation and the empire). Two decades later, the current parliament building was erected. The Reichstag delegates were elected by direct and equal male suffrage (and not the three-class electoral system prevailing in Prussia until 1918). The Reichstag did not participate in the appointment of the Chancellor until the parliamentary reforms of October 1918. After the Revolution of November 1918 and the establishment of the Weimar Constitution, women were given the right to vote for (and serve in) the Reichstag, and the parliament could use the no-confidence vote to force the chancellor or any cabinet member to resign. In March 1933, one month after the Reichstag fire, the then President of the Weimar Republic, Paul von Hindenburg, a retired war hero, gave Adolf Hitler ultimate power through the Decree for the Protection of People and State and the Enabling Act of 1933, although Hitler remained at the post of Federal Government Chancellor (though he called himself the Führer). After this, the Reichstag met only rarely, usually at the Krolloper (Kroll Opera House) to unanimously rubber-stamp the decisions of the government. It last convened on 26 April 1942.

With the new Constitution of 1949, the Bundestag was established as the new West German parliament. Because West Berlin was not officially under the jurisdiction of the Constitution, a legacy of the Cold War, the Bundestag met in Bonn in several different buildings, including (provisionally) a former waterworks facility. In addition, owing to the city's legal status, citizens of West Berlin were unable to vote in elections to the Bundestag, and were instead represented by 22 non-voting delegates[6] chosen by the House of Representatives, the city's legislature.[7]

The Bundeshaus in Bonn is the former parliament building of Germany. The sessions of the German Bundestag were held there from 1949 until its move to Berlin in 1999. Today it houses the International Congress Centre Bundeshaus Bonn and in the northern areas the branch office of the Bundesrat ("Federal Council"), which represents the Länder – the federated states. The southern areas became part of German offices for the United Nations in 2008.

The former Reichstag building housed a history exhibition (Fragen an die deutsche Geschichte) and served occasionally as a conference center. The Reichstag building was also occasionally used as a venue for sittings of the Bundestag and its committees and the Bundesversammlung (Federal Assembly), the body which elects the German Federal President. However, the Soviets harshly protested against the use of the Reichstag building by institutions of the Federal Republic of Germany and tried to disturb the sittings by flying supersonic jets close to the building.

Since April 19, 1999, the German parliament has again assembled in Berlin in its original Reichstag building, which was built in 1888 based on the plans of German architect Paul Wallot and underwent a significant renovation under the lead of British architect Lord Norman Foster. Parliamentary committees and subcommittees, public hearings and parliamentary group meetings take place in three auxiliary buildings, which surround the Reichstag building: the Jakob-Kaiser-Haus, Paul-Löbe-Haus and Marie-Elisabeth-Lüders-Haus.

In 2005, a small aircraft crashed close to the German Parliament. It was then decided to ban private air traffic over Central Berlin.

Tasks

The German Unity Flag is a national memorial to German Reunification that was raised on 3 October 1990; it waves in front of the Reichstag building in Berlin, seat of the Bundestag

Together with the Bundesrat, the Bundestag is the legislative branch of the German political system.

Although most legislation is initiated by the executive branch, the Bundestag considers the legislative function its most important responsibility, concentrating much of its energy on assessing and amending the government's legislative program. The committees (see below) play a prominent role in this process. Plenary sessions provide a forum for members to engage in public debate on legislative issues before them, but they tend to be well attended only when significant legislation is being considered.

The Bundestag members are the only federal officials directly elected by the public; the Bundestag in turn elects the Chancellor and, in addition, exercises oversight of the executive branch on issues of both substantive policy and routine administration. This check on executive power can be employed through binding legislation, public debates on government policy, investigations, and direct questioning of the chancellor or cabinet officials. For example, the Bundestag can conduct a question hour (Fragestunde), in which a government representative responds to a previously submitted written question from a member. Members can ask related questions during the question hour. The questions can concern anything from a major policy issue to a specific constituent's problem. Use of the question hour has increased markedly over the past forty years, with more than 20,000 questions being posed during the 1987–90 term. Understandably, the opposition parties are active in exercising the parliamentary right to scrutinize government actions.

Constituent service does also take place in the form of the Petition Committee. In 2004, the Petition Committee received over 18,000 complaints from citizens and was able to negotiate a mutually satisfactory solution to more than half of them. In 2005, as a pilot of the potential of internet petitions, a version of e-Petitioner was produced for the Bundestag. This was a collaborative project involving The Scottish Parliament, International Teledemocracy Centre and the Bundestag ‘Online Services Department’. The system was formally launched on 1 September 2005, and in 2008 the Bundestag moved to a new system based on its evaluation.[8]

Electoral term

The Bundestag is elected for four years, and new elections must be held between 46 and 48 months after the beginning of its electoral term, unless the Bundestag is dissolved prematurely. Its term ends when the next Bundestag convenes, which must occur within 30 days of the election.[9] Prior to 1976, there could be a period where one Bundestag had been dissolved and the next Bundestag could not be convened; during this period, the rights of the Bundestag were exercised by a so-called "Permanent Committee".[10]

Election

Germany uses the mixed-member proportional representation system, a system of proportional representation combined with elements of first-past-the-post voting. The Bundestag has 598 nominal members, elected for a four-year term; these seats are distributed between the sixteen German states in proportion to the states' population eligible to vote.[11]

Every elector has two votes: a constituency vote (first vote) and a party list vote (second vote). Based solely on the first votes, 299 members are elected in single-member constituencies by first-past-the-post voting. The second votes are used to produce a proportional number of seats for parties, first in the states, and then in the Bundestag. Seats are allocated using the Sainte-Laguë method. If a party wins fewer constituency seats in a state than its second votes would entitle it to, it receives additional seats from the relevant state list. Parties can file lists in every single state under certain conditions – for example, a fixed number of supporting signatures. Parties can receive second votes only in those states in which they have filed a state list.[11]

If a party, by winning single-member constituencies in one state, receives more seats than it would be entitled to according to its second vote share in that state (so-called overhang seats), the other parties receive compensation seats. Owing to this provision, the Bundestag usually has more than 598 members. The 19th and current Bundestag, for example, has 709 seats: 598 regular seats and 111 overhang and compensation seats. Overhang seats are calculated at the state level, so many more seats are added to balance this out among the different states, adding more seats than would be needed to compensate for overhang at the national level in order to avoid negative vote weight.[11]

In order to qualify for seats based on the party-list vote share, a party must either win three single-member constituencies via first votes or exceed a threshold of 5% of the second votes nationwide. If a party only wins one or two single-member constituencies and fails to get at least 5% of the second votes, it keeps the single-member seat(s), but other parties that accomplish at least one of the two threshold conditions receive compensation seats.[11] In the most recent example of this, during the 2002 election, the PDS won only 4.0% of the second votes nationwide, but won two constituencies in the state of Berlin.[12] The same applies if an independent candidate wins a single-member constituency,[11] which has not happened since the 1949 election.[12]

If a voter cast a first vote for a successful independent candidate or a successful candidate whose party failed to qualify for proportional representation, his or her second vote does not count toward proportional representation. However, it does count toward whether the elected party exceeds the 5% threshold.[11]

Parties representing recognized national minorities (currently Danes, Frisians, Sorbs, and Romani people) are exempt from the 5% threshold, but normally only run in state elections.[11]

Bundestag ballot: constituency vote on left, party list (showing top five list candidates) vote on right

Election result

The last Federal elections were held on Sunday, 24 September 2017, to elect the members of the 19th Bundestag.

The election saw the CDU/CSU win 33% of the vote, a drop of more than 8% and its lowest share of the vote since 1949, while the SPD also suffered its worst result since the 1949 with just 20% of the vote. Alternative for Germany (AfD)—which was previously unrepresented in the Bundestag—became the third largest party in the Bundestag with 12.6% of the vote and a plurality of the vote in Saxony. The FDP reentered the Bundestag after its exodus following the 2013 election loss where they fell under the 5% vote threshold:They had a result of 10.7%. The Left and the Greens obtain marginal increaces of 0.6% and 0.5% coming in at totals of 9.2% and 8.9% respectively. No party won an outright majority in any state, including Bavaria, where the CSU often wins majorities and won a majority of the vote in 2013.

Party Constituency Party list Total
seats
+/–
Votes % Seats Votes % Seats
Christian Democratic Union (CDU)[lower-alpha 7]14,030,75130.218512,447,65626.815200−55
Social Democratic Party (SPD)11,429,23124.6599,539,38120.594153−40
Alternative for Germany (AfD)5,317,49911.535,878,11512.69194+94
Free Democratic Party (FDP)3,249,2387.004,999,44910.78080+80
The Left (DIE LINKE)3,966,6378.654,297,2709.26469+5
Alliance 90/The Greens (GRÜNE)3,717,9228.014,158,4008.96667+4
Christian Social Union in Bavaria (CSU)[lower-alpha 7]3,255,4877.0462,869,6886.2046−10
Free Voters589,0561.30463,2921.0000
Die PARTEI245,6590.50454,3491.0000
Human Environment Animal Protection22,9170.00374,1790.8000
National Democratic Party45,1690.10176,0200.4000
Pirate Party Germany93,1960.20173,4760.4000
Ecological Democratic Party166,2280.40144,8090.3000
Basic Income Alliance97,5390.200New
V-Partei³1,2010.0064,0730.100New
German Centre63,2030.100New
Democracy in Motion60,9140.100New
Bavaria Party62,6220.1058,0370.1000
AD-DEMOCRATS41,2510.100New
Animal Protection Alliance6,1140.0032,2210.100New
Marxist–Leninist Party of Germany35,7600.1029,7850.1000
Healthresearch1,5370.0023,4040.100New
German Communist Party7,5170.0011,5580.000New
Human World2,2050.0011,6610.000New
The Greys4,3000.0010,0090.000New
Bürgerrechtsbewegung Solidarität15,9600.006,6930.0000
The Humanists5,9910.000New
Magdeburger Garden Party2,5700.005,6170.000New
Alliance for Germany6,3160.009,6310.0000
you.7720.003,0320.000New
The Right1,1420.002,0540.000New
Socialist Equality Party9030.001,2910.0000
Bergpartei, die "ÜberPartei"6720.009110.000New
Party of Reason2420.005330.0000
The Violets – for Spiritual Politics2,1760.0000
Alliance C1,7170.000New
New Liberals8840.000New
The Union3710.000New
Family Party5060.0000
The Women4390.000New
Renter's Party1,3520.000New
Others100,8890.200
Independents2,4580.0000
Invalid/blank votes586,726460,849
Total46,976,34110029946,976,341100410709+78
Registered voters/turnout61,688,48576.261,688,48576.2
Source: Bundeswahlleiter

List of Bundestag by session

Seat distribution in the German Bundestag (at the beginning of each session)
Session Election Seats CDU/CSU SPD FDP GRÜNE[lower-alpha 8] DIE LINKE[lower-alpha 9] AfD Others
Sonstige
1st1949 40213913152  80[lower-alpha 10]
2nd1953 48724315148  45[lower-alpha 11]
3rd1957 4972701694117[lower-alpha 12]
4th1961 49924219067
5th1965 49624520249
6th1969 49624222430
7th1972 49622523041
8th1976 49624321439
9th1980 49722621853
10th1983 4982441933427
11th1987 4972231864642
12th1990 66231923979817
13th1994 672294252474930
14th1998 669245298434736
15th2002 60324825147552
16th2005 614226222615154
17th2009 622239146936876
18th2013 6303111926364
19th2017 70924615380676994
  Parties in the ruling coalition
Seat distribution in the Bundestag from 1949 to 2017
  Left
  SPD
  Green
  FDP
  AfD

Parties that were only present between 1949 and 1957

  Others
  Centre
  DP
  GB/BHE

Presidents since 1949

Presidents of the Bundestag
Name Party Beginning of term End of term Length of term
1 Erich Köhler (1892–1958) CDU 7 September 1949 18 October 1950[lower-alpha 13] 1 year, 41 days
2 Hermann Ehlers (1904–1954) CDU 19 October 1950 29 October 1954[lower-alpha 14] 4 years, 10 days
3 Eugen Gerstenmaier (1906–1986) CDU 16 November 1954 31 January 1969[lower-alpha 15] 14 years, 76 days
4 Kai-Uwe von Hassel (1913–1997) CDU 5 February 1969 13 December 1972 3 years, 312 days
5 Annemarie Renger[lower-alpha 16] (1919–2008) SPD 13 December 1972 14 December 1976 4 years, 1 day
6 Karl Carstens (1914–1992) CDU 14 December 1976 31 May 1979[lower-alpha 17] 2 years, 168 days
7 Richard Stücklen (1916–2002) CSU 31 May 1979 29 March 1983 3 years, 363 days
8 Rainer Barzel (1924–2006) CDU 29 March 1983 25 October 1984[lower-alpha 18] 1 year, 210 days
9 Philipp Jenninger (1932-2018) CDU 5 November 1984 11 November 1988[lower-alpha 19] 4 years, 6 days
10 Rita Süssmuth (b. 1937) CDU 25 November 1988 26 October 1998 9 years, 335 days
11 Wolfgang Thierse (b. 1943) SPD 26 October 1998 18 October 2005 6 years, 357 days
12 Norbert Lammert (b. 1948) CDU 18 October 2005 24 October 2017 12 years, 6 days
13 Wolfgang Schäuble (b. 1942) CDU 24 October 2017 present 2 years, 245 days

Organization

The Marie-Elisabeth-Lüders-Haus, one of the official buildings of the complex, housing the parliamentary library

Parliamentary groups

The most important organisational structures within the Bundestag are parliamentary groups (Fraktionen; sing. Fraktion), which are traditionally formed by political parties who win at least 5% of the "second vote." The CDU and CSU have always formed a single united Fraktion. The size of a party's Fraktion determines the extent of its representation on legislative committees, the time slots allotted for speaking, the number of committee chairs it can hold, and its representation in executive bodies of the Bundestag. The Fraktionen, not the members, receive the bulk of government funding for legislative and administrative activities.

The leadership of each Fraktion consists of a parliamentary party leader, several deputy leaders, and an executive committee. The leadership's major responsibilities are to represent the Fraktion, enforce party discipline and orchestrate the party's parliamentary activities. The members of each Fraktion are distributed among working groups focused on specific policy-related topics such as social policy, economics, and foreign policy. The Fraktion meets every Tuesday afternoon in the weeks in which the Bundestag is in session to consider legislation before the Bundestag and formulate the party's position on it.

Parties that do not cross the 5% threshold but win at least three seats by direct elections (i.e. which have at least three MPs representing a constituency seat) can be granted the status of a group in the Bundestag. This applied to the Party of Democratic Socialism (PDS) from 1990–1998. This status entails some privileges which are in general less than those of a Fraktion. In the current Bundestag, there are no such groups (the PDS had only two constituency MPs in parliament until 2005 and could thus not even considered a group anymore; the party—now The Left—has held full Fraktion status in the Bundestag since 2005).

Executive bodies

The Bundestag's executive bodies include the Council of Elders and the Presidium. The council consists of the Bundestag leadership, together with the most senior representatives of each Fraktion, with the number of these representatives tied to the strength of the Parliamentary groups in the chamber. The council is the coordination hub, determining the daily legislative agenda and assigning committee chairpersons based on Parliamentary group representation. The council also serves as an important forum for interparty negotiations on specific legislation and procedural issues. The Presidium is responsible for the routine administration of the Bundestag, including its clerical and research activities. It consists of the chamber's president (usually elected from the largest Fraktion) and vice presidents (one from each Fraktion).

Committees

Most of the legislative work in the Bundestag is the product of standing committees, which exist largely unchanged throughout one legislative period. The number of committees approximates the number of federal ministries, and the titles of each are roughly similar (e.g., defense, agriculture, and labor). There are, as of the current nineteenth Bundestag, 24 standing committees. The distribution of committee chairs and the membership of each committee reflect the relative strength of the various Parliamentary groups in the chamber. In the current nineteenth Bundestag, the CDU/CSU chaired ten committees, the SPD five, the AfD and the FDP three each, The Left and the Greens two each. Members of the opposition party can chair a significant number of standing committees (e.g. the budget committee is always chaired by the biggest opposition party). These committees have either a small staff or no staff at all.

Principle of discontinuation

As is the case with some other parliaments, the Bundestag is subject to the principle of discontinuation, meaning that a newly elected Bundestag is legally regarded to be a body and entity completely different from the previous Bundestag. This leads to the result that any motion, application or action submitted to the previous Bundestag, e.g. a bill referred to the Bundestag by the Federal Government, is regarded as void by non-decision (German terminology: "Die Sache fällt der Diskontinuität anheim"). Thus any bill that has not been decided upon by the beginning of the new electoral period must be brought up by the government again if it aims to uphold the motion, this procedure in effect delaying the passage of the bill. Furthermore, any newly elected Bundestag will have to freshly decide on the rules of procedure (Geschäftsordnung), which is done by a formal decision of taking over such rules from the preceding Bundestag by reference.

Any Bundestag is considered dissolved only once a newly elected Bundestag has actually gathered in order to constitute itself (Article 39 sec. 1 sentence 2 of the Basic Law), which has to happen within 30 days of its election (Article 39 sec. 2 of the Basic Law). Thus, it may happen (and has happened) that the old Bundestag gathers and makes decisions even after the election of a new Bundestag that has not gathered in order to constitute itself. For example, elections to the 16th Bundestag took place on 18 September 2005,[13] but the 15th Bundestag still convened after election day to make some decisions on German military engagement abroad,[14] and was entitled to do so, as the newly elected 16th Bundestag did not convene for the first time until 18 October 2005.[15]

See also

Notes

  1. The Rules of Procedure of the Bundestag (Geschäftsordnung) allow for each political group (Fraktion) to have a Vice-President, however, the Bundestag must still elect these by Absolute Majority. It is Parliamentary Tradition to vote for Vice-Presidents even if they are not in your Fraktion, however due to the AfD's political position there has been a general refusal to vote for their Vice-Presidential candidates on numerous occasions. Because of this the AfD has no Vice-President.
  2. Paragraphs 38 to 49
  3. Article 38 Section 1 Grundgesetz
  4. Paragraph 1 Section 1 of the Federal Elections Act (Bundeswahlgesetz)
  5. German Citizens are defined in Article 116 Grundgesetz
  6. Article 38 Section 2 Grundgesetz: Any person who has attained the age of eighteen shall be entitled to vote; any person who has attained the age of majority may be elected.
  7. The Christian Democratic Union and the Christian Social Union of Bavaria call themselves sister parties. They do not compete against each other in the same states and they form one group within the Bundestag.
  8. 1983 to 1994 The Greens and 1990 to 1994 Alliance 90, since 1994 Alliance 90/The Greens
  9. 1990 to 2005 PDS (Party of Democratic Socialism), 2005 to 2007 The Left Party.PDS, since 2007 The Left
  10. DP 17, BP 17, KPD 15, WAV 12, Centre Party 10, DKP-DRP 5, SSW 1, Independents 3
  11. DP 15, GB-BHE 27, Centre Party 3
  12. DP
  13. resigned for medical reasons
  14. died in office
  15. resigned for political reasons
  16. first woman to hold the post
  17. Elected President of Germany
  18. resigned for political reasons
  19. resigned for political reasons

References

  1. "Deutscher Bundestag - Sitzverteilung des 19. Deutschen Bundestages" (in German). Bundestag.de. 29 September 2016. Retrieved 7 September 2019.
  2. "Auf einen Blick" (PDF). www.btg-bestellservice.de. Retrieved 7 September 2019.
  3. Grundgesetz für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland (PDF) (23.12.2014 ed.). Bonn: Parlamentarischer Rat. 8 May 1949. Retrieved 19 June 2016.
  4. "Plenarsaal "Deutscher Bundestag" – The Path of Democracy". www.wegderdemokratie.de. Retrieved 11 December 2019.
  5. Online Etymology Dictionary — Bundestag
  6. Germany at the Polls: The Bundestag Elections of the 1980s, Karl H. Cerny, Duke University Press, 1990, page 34
  7. GERMANY (FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF) Date of Elections: 5 October 1980, International Parliamentary Union
  8. Trenel, M. (2007). "Öffentliche Petitionen beim deutschen Bundestag - erste Ergebnisse der Evaluation des Modellversuchs = An Evaluation Study of Public Petitions at the German Parliament" (PDF). TAB Brief Nr 32. Deutscher Bundestag. Archived from the original (PDF) on 16 March 2009. Retrieved 16 June 2009.
  9. "Basic Law, Article 39: Electoral term – Convening". Retrieved 29 September 2017.
  10. Schäfer, Friedrich (2013). Der Bundestag: Eine Darstellung seiner Aufgaben und seiner Arbeitsweise [The Bundestag: Its tasks and procedures] (in German). VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften. p. 28. ISBN 9783322836434.
  11. Martin Fehndrich; Wilko Zicht; Matthias Cantow (22 September 2017). "Wahlsystem der Bundestagswahl". Wahlrecht.de. Retrieved 26 September 2017.
  12. "Ergebnisse früherer Bundestagswahlen" (PDF). Der Bundeswahlleiter. 18 August 2017. Retrieved 26 September 2017.
  13. "Verkürzte Fristen zur vorgezogenen Neuwahl des Deutschen Bundestages" (Press release). Bundeswahlleiter. 25 July 2005. Archived from the original on 7 October 2007. Retrieved 20 October 2008.
  14. "Stenographischer Bericht der 187. Sitzung des 15. Deutschen Bundestages am 28. September 2005" [Stenographic report of the 187th session of the 15th Deutscher Bundestag on 2005-09-28] (PDF). Deutscher Bundestag. 28 September 2005. Retrieved 20 October 2008.
  15. "Stenographischer Bericht der 1. Sitzung des 16. Deutschen Bundestages am 18. Oktober 2005" [Stenographic report of the 1st session of the 16th Deutscher Bundestag on 2005-10-18] (PDF). Deutscher Bundestag. 18 October 2005. Retrieved 20 October 2008.

This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.