Ripple (payment protocol)

Ripple
Original author(s) Arthur Britto, David Schwartz, Ryan Fugger
Developer(s) Ripple
Initial release 2012
Stable release
1.0.0[1] / 15 May 2018[1]
Repository
Edit this at Wikidata
Written in C++
Operating system Server: GNU/Linux (RHEL, CentOS, Ubuntu), Windows, macOS (development only)
Type Real-time gross settlement, currency exchange, remittance
License ISC license[2]
Website developers.ripple.com/xrp-ledger-overview.html

Ripple is a real-time gross settlement system, currency exchange and remittance network created by Ripple Labs Inc., a US-based technology company. Ripple is built upon a distributed open source internet protocol, and supports tokens representing fiat currency, cryptocurrency, commodities, or other units of value such as frequent flier miles or mobile minutes.[3][4] Released in 2012, Ripple purports to enable "secure, instantly and nearly free global financial transactions of any size with no chargebacks."

Ripple is based around a shared public ledger,[5] the XRP Ledger,[6] which uses a consensus process that allows for payments, exchanges and remittance in a distributed process. The network can operate without the Ripple company;[7] among its validators are companies, internet service providers, and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.[8][9] The ledger employs the decentralized native cryptocurrency known as XRP, which as of September 2018 was the third largest coin by market capitalization.[10][11]

Used by companies such as UniCredit, UBS and Santander, Ripple has been increasingly adopted by banks and payment networks as settlement infrastructure technology,[12] with American Banker explaining that "from banks' perspective, distributed ledgers like the Ripple system have a number of advantages over cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin."[13]

History

Early development (2004–12)

The predecessor to the Ripple payment protocol, Ripplepay, was first developed in 2004 by Ryan Fugger,[14][15] a web developer in Vancouver, British Columbia.[16] Fugger conceived of the idea after working on a local exchange trading system in Vancouver, and his intent was to create a monetary system that was decentralized and could effectively allow individuals and communities to create their own money. Fugger's first iteration of this system, RipplePay.com,[17] debuted in 2005 as a financial service to provide secure payment options to members of an online community via a global network.[16][18]

This led to the conception of a new system by Jed McCaleb of eDonkey network,[19] which was designed and built by Arthur Britto and David Schwartz.[20] In May 2011, they began developing a digital currency system in which transactions were verified by consensus among members of the network, rather than by the mining process used by bitcoin, which relies on blockchain ledgers.[17] This new version of the Ripple system[16] was therefore designed to eliminate bitcoin's reliance on centralized exchanges, use less electricity than bitcoin, and perform transactions much more quickly than bitcoin.[16] Chris Larsen,[17] who had previously founded the lending services companies E-Loan and Prosper, joined the team in August 2012,[19] and together McCaleb and Larsen approached Ryan Fugger with their digital currency idea. After discussions with long-standing members of the Ripple community, Fugger handed over the reins.[17] In September 2012 the team co-founded the corporation OpenCoin,[17] or OpenCoin Inc.[19][21]

OpenCoin and Ripple Labs (2012–13)

OpenCoin began developing a new payment protocol called the Ripple Transaction Protocol (RTXP) based on Ryan Fugger's concepts.[17] The Ripple protocol enables the instant and direct transfer of money between two parties.[22] As such the protocol can circumnavigate the fees and wait times of the traditional correspondent banking system,[22][23] and any type of currency can be exchanged including U.S. dollars, euros, renminbis, Indian rupees, yen, gold and airline miles.[24] To maintain security OpenCoin programmed Ripple to rely on a common ledger that is "managed by a network of independent validating servers that constantly compare their transaction records." Servers could belong to anyone, including banks or market makers.[22] The company also created its own form of digital currency dubbed XRP in a manner similar to bitcoin, using the currency to allow financial institutions to transfer money with negligible fees and wait-time.[25]

Among OpenCoin's early investors were[26] Andreessen Horowitz and Google Ventures.[22] On July 1, 2013, XRP Fund II, LLC (now called simply XRP II)[27] was incorporated as a wholly owned subsidiary of OpenCoin, and headquartered in South Carolina.[27] The following day, Ripple announced its linking of the bitcoin and Ripple protocols via the Bitcoin Bridge. The bitcoin Bridge allows Ripple users to send a payment in any currency to a bitcoin address.[28][29] Ripple also developed early partnerships with companies such as ZipZap.[30] On September 26, 2013, OpenCoin Inc. changed its name to Ripple Labs Inc.,[21] with Chris Larsen remaining CEO.[31] On the same day the Ripple reference server and client became free software, released as open source under the terms of the ISC license.[2] Ripple Labs continued as the primary contributors of code to the consensus verification system behind Ripple, which can "integrate with banks’ existing networks."[32] In October 2013, Ripple partnered further with ZipZap, with the relationship called a threat to Western Union in the press.[33]

Focus on banking market (2014–17)

By 2014, Ripple Labs was involved in several development projects related to the protocol, releasing for example an iOS client app for the iPhone that allows iPhone users to send and receive any currency via their phones.[34][35][36] This Ripple Client app no longer exists.[37] In July 2014, Ripple Labs proposed Codius, a project to develop a new smart contract system that is "programming language agnostic."[38]

"...we think that the bigger opportunity is not just to create another digital currency – there are plenty of those - but rather to use that technology as a way of building a settlement system with no central operator."
— Ripple CEO Chris Larsen in December 2014[24]

Since 2013, the protocol has been adopted by an increasing number of financial institutions to "[offer] an alternative remittance option" to consumers.[39] Ripple allows for cross-border payments for retail customers, corporations, and other banks, and Larsen was quoted stating that "Ripple simplifies the [exchange] process by creating point-to-point and transparent transfers in which banks do not have to pay corresponding bank fees."[24] The first bank to use Ripple was Fidor Bank in Munich, which announced the partnership in early 2014. Fidor is an online-only bank based in Germany.[40] That September the New Jersey-based Cross River Bank and Kansas-based CBW Bank announced they would be using the Ripple protocol.[41] By December Ripple Labs began working with global payments service Earthport, combining Ripple's software with Earthport's payment services system. Earthport's clients include banks such as Bank of America and HSBC, and it operates in 65 countries. The partnership marked the first network usage of the Ripple protocol.[42] In December 2014 alone, the XRP price value rose over 200%, helping Ripple surpass litecoin to become the second biggest crypto-currency, and setting Ripple's market capitalization at close to half a billion dollars.[43] On December 29, 2017, XRP briefly became the second largest cryptocurrency, with a market capitalization of 73 billion USD.[44]

In February 2015, Fidor Bank announced they would be using the Ripple protocol to implement a new real-time international money transfer network,[45] and in late April 2015, it was announced that Western Union was planning to "experiment" with Ripple.[33] In late May 2015, Commonwealth Bank of Australia announced it would be experimenting with Ripple[46] in relation to intrabank transfers.[47] Since 2012, representatives of Ripple Labs have professed support for government regulation of the crypto-currency market, claiming that regulations help businesses grow.[48] On May 5, 2015, FinCEN fined Ripple Labs and XRP II US$700,000 for violation of the Bank Secrecy Act,[27] based on the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network's additions to the act in 2013.[49] Ripple Labs agreed to remedial steps to ensure future compliance, which included an agreement to only transact XRP and "Ripple Trade" activity through registered money services businesses (MSB), among other agreements such as enhancing the Ripple Protocol.[27] The enhancement won't change the protocol itself, but will instead add AML transaction monitoring to the network and improve transaction analysis.[49] As of 2017, the current release of the server (known as rippled) is version 0.70.1.[1]

On June 13, 2016, Ripple obtained a virtual currency license from the New York State Department of Financial Services, making it the fourth company with a BitLicense.[50] On August 19, 2016, SBI Ripple Asia announced the creation of a Japanese consortium of banks in a new network that will use Ripple’s technology for payments and settlement.[51] The consortium was officially launched on October 25, 2016 with 42 member banks.[52] As of July 2017, 61 Japanese banks had joined, representing over 80% of total banking assets in Japan.[53]

On September 23, 2016, Ripple announced the creation of the first interbank group for global payments based on distributed financial technology. As of April 2017, members of the network known as the Global Payments Steering Group (GPSG) are Bank of America Merrill Lynch, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group, Royal Bank of Canada, Santander, Standard Chartered, UniCredit and Westpac Banking Corporation. The group will "oversee the creation and maintenance of Ripple payment transaction rules, formalized standards for activity using Ripple, and other actions to support the implementation of Ripple payment capabilities."[54][55]

In September 2018, PNC Financial Services announced it will use Ripple's xCurrent system in international payments. xCurrent is a "bi-directional messaging" system which can be integrated with blockchains. PNC will not use XRP or Ripple's blockchain-based xRapid system.[56]

Concept

"...as an open protocol, Ripple enables a peer-to-peer server architecture to facilitate the movement of value among financial institutions. This allows financial services companies to make payments directly to each other, whether across different networks, geographic borders or currencies."
— Consultative Group to Assist the Poor in 2015[57]

Ripple's website describes the open-source protocol as "basic infrastructure technology for interbank transactions – a neutral utility for financial institutions and systems." The protocol allows banks and non-bank financial services companies to incorporate the Ripple protocol into their own systems, and therefore allow their customers to use the service.[58] Currently, Ripple requires two parties for a transaction to occur: first, a regulated financial institution "holds funds and issues balances on behalf of customers." Second, "market makers" such as hedge funds or currency trading desks provide liquidity in the currency they want to trade in.[59] At its core, Ripple is based around a shared, public database or ledger that has its contents decided on by consensus.[5] In addition to balances, the ledger holds information about offers to buy or sell currencies and assets, creating the first distributed exchange.[58] The consensus process allows for payments, exchanges and remittance in a distributed process.[60] According to the CGAP in 2015, "Ripple does for payments what SMTP did for email, which is enable the systems of different financial institutions to communicate directly."[57]

In Ripple, users make payments between each other by using cryptographically signed transactions denominated in either fiat currencies or Ripple's internal currency (XRP). For XRP-denominated transactions Ripple can make use of its internal ledger, while for payments denominated in other assets, the Ripple ledger only records the amounts owed, with assets represented as debt obligations.[14] As originally Ripple only kept records in its ledger and has no real-world enforcement power, trust was required.[14] However, Ripple is now integrated with various user verification protocols and bank services.[61] Users have to specify which other users they trust and to what amount.[14] When a non-XRP payment is made between two users that trust each other, the balance of the mutual credit line is adjusted, subject to limits set by each user. In order to send assets between users that have not directly established a trust relationship, the system tries to find a path between the two users such that each link of the path is between two users that do have a trust relationship. All balances along the path are then adjusted simultaneously and atomically.[14] This mechanism of making payments through a network of trusted associates is named 'rippling'. It has similarities to the age-old hawala system.[62]

Design features

Gateways

A gateway is any person or organization that enables users to put money into and take money out of Ripple's liquidity pool.[2] A gateway accepts currency deposits from users and issues balances into Ripple's distributed ledger. Furthermore, gateways redeem ledger balances against the deposits they hold when currency is withdrawn. In practice, gateways are similar to banks, yet they share one global ledger known as the Ripple protocol. Depending on the type and degree of interaction a user has with a gateway, the gateway may have anti-money laundering (AML) or know your customer (KYC) policies requiring verification of identification, address, nationality, etc. to prevent criminal activity.[4] Popular gateways as of 2017 included Bitstamp, Kraken, Gatehub, Ripple Fox, Tokyo JPY, Mr. Ripple, RippleChina and The Rock Trading.[63]

Trustlines and rippling

Users must ‘extend trust’ to the Ripple gateway that holds their deposit. This manual creation of a trustline indicates to the Ripple network that the user is comfortable with the gateway’s counterparty risk. Furthermore, the user must put a quantitative limit on this trust and create a similar limit for each currency on deposit at that gateway. For example, if a user deposits US$50 and BTC2.00 at The Rock Trading, the user will have to grant trust of at least that much in both currencies to the gateway for the monies to be available in the Ripple network.[64] When a user has allowed multiple gateways in the same currency, there is an advanced option to allow "rippling," which subjects the user’s balance of that currency to switch (or ripple) between gateways. Though their total balance doesn't alter, users earn a small transit fee for providing inter-gateway liquidity.[65]

Creditworthiness

Similar to reasons during the Free Banking Era in the United States, the value of a currency can vary significantly depending on a gateway's creditworthiness. A non-profit trade association, the International Ripple Business Association (IRBA), provides unified procedures and disclosure standards for gateways.[66][67][68] As of June 2015, fifteen businesses had met or exceeded the IRBA standards.[66][67]

Consensus ledger

Ripple relies on a common shared ledger, which is a distributed database storing information about all Ripple accounts. The network is "managed by a network of independent validating servers that constantly compare their transaction records." Servers could belong to anyone, including banks or market makers.[22] Though the Ripple protocol is freeware,[2] Ripple Labs continues to develop and promote the Ripple protocol, which confirms financial transactions via a network of distributed servers. Ripple Labs is currently assisting banks in integrating with the Ripple network.[32] A new ledger is created every few seconds,[69] and the last closed ledger is a perfect record of all Ripple accounts as determined by the network of servers. A transaction is any proposed change to the ledger and can be introduced by any server to the network. The servers attempt to come to consensus about a set of transactions to apply to the ledger, creating a new ‘last closed ledger’.[69]

The consensus process is distributed,[70] and the goal of consensus is for each server to apply the same set of transactions to the current ledger.[69] Servers continually receive transactions from other servers on the network,[69] and the server determines which transactions to apply based on if a transaction came from a specified node in the ‘unique node list’ (UNL).[60] Transactions that are agreed upon by a "supermajority" of peers are considered validated.[69] If the supermajority isn't in consensus, "this implies that transaction volume was too high or network latency too great for the consensus process to produce consistent proposals," then the consensus process is again attempted by the nodes. Each round of consensus reduces disagreement, until the supermajority is reached.[69] The intended outcome of this process is that disputed transactions are discarded from proposals while widely accepted transactions are included.While users may assemble their own UNL nodes and have full control over which nodes they trust, Ripple Labs acknowledges that most people will use the default UNL supplied by their client.

Ledger security

In early 2014,[71] a rival company called the Stellar Foundation[72] experienced a network crash.[73] The company brought in David Mazieres, Stellar's chief scientist and head of Stanford University's secure computing group, to conduct a review of the Stellar consensus system, which was similar to Ripple's. Mazieres declared the Stellar system unlikely to be safe when operating with "more than one validating node,"[73] arguing that when consensus is not reached, a ledger fork occurs with parts of the network disagreeing over accepted transactions.[74] The Stellar Foundation afterwards claimed that there was an "innate weaknesses" in the consensus process,[73] a claim which according to Finance Magnates, "Ripple vehemently denied."[71] Ripple Labs chief cryptographer David Schwartz disputed Mazieres' findings and declared that Stellar had incorrectly implemented the consensus system, as "the protocol provides safety and fault tolerance assuming the validators are configured correctly."[74] The company further wrote that after examining Stellar's information, they had concluded "that there is no threat to the continued operation of the Ripple network."[75]

Use as a payment/forex system

Ripple allows users or businesses to conduct cross-currency transactions[76] in 3 to 5 seconds.[58] All accounts and transactions are cryptographically secure and algorithmically verified. Payments can only be authorized by the account holder and all payments are processed automatically without any third parties or intermediaries.[76] Ripple validates accounts and balances instantly for payment transmission and delivers payment notification with very little latency (within a few seconds).[77] Payments are irreversible, and there are no chargebacks.[78] XRP cannot be frozen or seized.[79] While as of 2014 anyone could open an account on Ripple,[79] by 2015 identity verification procedures had been implemented.[61] Ripple's Path-finding Algorithm searches for the fastest, cheapest path between two currencies.[80] In the case of a user who wants to send a payment from USD to EUR, this could be a "one-hop" path directly from USD to EUR, or it could be a multi-hop path, perhaps from USD to CAD to XRP to EUR.[81] Path finding is designed to seek out the cheapest conversion cost for the user. As of May 14, 2014, Ripple's gateways allow deposits in a limited number of fiat currencies (USD, EUR, MXN, NZD, GBP, NOK, JPY, CAD, CHF, CNY, AUD), a handful of crypto currencies (BTC, XRP, LTC, NMC, NXT, PPC, XVN, SLL) and a few commodities (gold, silver, platinum).[82][83][84]

The Bitcoin Bridge

The bitcoin bridge is a link between the Ripple and bitcoin ecosystems. The bridge makes it possible to pay any bitcoin user straight from a Ripple account without ever needing to hold any of the digital currency. Additionally, any merchant accepting bitcoins has the potential to accept any currency in the world. For example, a Ripple user may prefer to keep money in USD and not own bitcoins. A merchant, however, may desire payment in bitcoin. The bitcoin bridge allows any Ripple user to send bitcoins without having to use a central exchange such as BTC-e to acquire them.[29][85] Bitstamp acts as a gateway for the Ripple payment protocol, among other exchanges.

Privacy

While transaction information on the ledger is public, payment information is not. It’s thus difficult for anyone to associate transaction information with any specific user or corporation.[86]

Market makers

Any user on Ripple can act as a market maker by offering an arbitrage service such as providing market liquidity, intra-gateway currency conversion, rippling, etc. Market makers can also be hedge funds or currency trading desks. According to the Ripple website, "by holding balances in multiple currencies and connecting to multiple gateways, market makers facilitate payments between users where no direct trust exists, enabling exchanges across gateways."[87] With a sufficient number of market makers, the path finding algorithm creates a near frictionless market and enables users to seamlessly pay each other via the network in different currencies, without assuming any undesired foreign exchange risk.[88]

Ripple can be used to trade or convert currencies, to send money in one currency and the recipient to receive it in another currency.[88] For example, a user can pay with USD and the recipient can choose to receive the money in another currency, including bitcoins and XRP.[88]

Open API

Ripple Labs built the protocol to be friendly to the developer community, and resulting features include an API for its payment network, based on the popular REST API standard. One of the earliest extensions by third-party developers was a Ripple extension to e-commerce platform Magento, which enables Magento to read the Ripple public ledger and create an invoice. There has been a Ripple Wallet payment option developed for retail situations as well.[34]

XRP

XRP
Ticker symbol XRP
Website https://ripple.com/xrp/
Ledger
Block explorer https://xrp.co
Circulating supply 39,650,153,121 XRP (as of 30 August 2018)
Supply limit 100,000,000,000 XRP
Valuation
Exchange rate Increase US$0.40 (as of 21 September 2018)
Market cap Increase US$21 billion (as of 21 September 2018)

    XRP is the native currency of the Ripple network. XRP are currently divisible to 6 decimal places, and the smallest unit is called a drop with 1 million drops equaling 1 XRP.[90] There were 100 billion XRP created at Ripple's inception, with no more allowed to be created according to the protocol's rules.[91] As such, the system was designed so XRP is an asset with decreasing available supply.[91] Not dependent on any third party for redemption, XRP is the only currency in the Ripple network that does not entail counterparty risk, and it is the only native digital asset. The other currencies in the Ripple network are debt instruments (i.e. liabilities), and exist in the form of balances.[2] Users of the Ripple network are not required to use XRP as a store of value or a medium of exchange. Each Ripple account is required, however, to have a small reserve of 20 XRP[92] (US$6.65 as of August 21, 2018).[93] The purpose for this requirement is discussed in the anti-spam section.

    XRP settles payments in 3–4 seconds which is considerably faster than Bitcoin. XRP can handle 1,500 transactions per second, and can scale to handle the same throughput as Visa (which is 50,000 transactions per second, as of July 15, 2017.) The current minimum transaction cost required by the network for a standard transaction is 0.00001 XRP, which is considerably less than Bitcoin.

    Distribution

    Cryptocurrency market capitalizations as of 27 January 2018, in billions of US dollars, with Ripple at top right.[94]

    Of the 100 billion created, 20 billion XRP were retained by the creators, who were also the founders of Ripple Labs. The creators gave the remaining 80% of the total to Ripple Labs, with the XRP intended "to incentivize market maker activity to increase XRP liquidity and strengthen the overall health of XRP markets."[91][95] Ripple Labs also had a short-lived 2013 giveaway of under 200 million XRP (0.2% of all XRP) with some of the amount given to charities such as the Computing for Good initiative, which began offering XRP in exchange for time volunteered on research projects.[96] As of March 2015, 67% of Ripple Labs's original 80% was still retained by the company,[91] with Ripple Labs stating that "we will engage in distribution strategies that we expect will result in a stable or strengthening XRP exchange rate against other currencies."[97] In May 2017, to alleviate concerns surrounding XRP supply, Ripple committed to place 55 billion XRP (88% of its XRP holdings) into a cryptographically-secured escrow. The escrow will allow them to use up to 1 billion monthly and return whatever is unused at the end of each month to the back of the escrow queue in the form of an additional month-long contract, starting the process all over.[98][95] The amount of XRP distributed and their movement can be tracked through the Ripple Charts website.[99]

    As a bridge currency

    One of the specific functions of XRP is as a bridge currency,[81] which can be necessary if no direct exchange is available between two currencies at a specific time,[100] for example when transacting between two rarely traded currency pairs.[89] Within the network’s currency exchange, XRP are traded freely against other currencies, and its market price fluctuates against dollars, euros, yen, bitcoin, etc. Ripple's design focus is as a currency exchange and a distributed real-time gross settlement system, as opposed to emphasizing XRP as an alternative currency.[89] In April 2015, Ripple Labs announced that a new feature called autobridging had been added to Ripple, with the intent of making it easier for market makers to transact between rarely traded currency pairs. The feature is also intended to expose more of the network to liquidity and better FX rates.[101]

    As an anti-spam measure

    When a user conducts a financial transaction in a non-native currency, Ripple charges a transaction fee. The purpose of the fees is to protect against network flooding by making the attacks too expensive for hackers. If Ripple were completely free to access, adversaries could broadcast large amounts of "ledger spam" (i.e. fake accounts) and "transaction spam" (i.e. fake transactions) in an attempt to overload the network. This could cause the size of the ledger to become unmanageable and interfere with the network’s ability to quickly settle legitimate transactions. Thus, to engage in trade, each Ripple account is required to have a small reserve of 20 XRP,[92] (US$4.96 as of December 5, 2017[93]), and a transaction fee starting at .00001 XRP (US$0.000002 as of December 5, 2017[93]) must be spent for each trade. This transaction fee is not collected by anyone; the XRP is destroyed and ceases to exist.[102] The transaction fee rises if the user posts trades at an enormous rate (many thousands per minute), and resettles after a period of inactivity.[64]

    Partnerships

    Many companies have announced experimenting and integrations with Ripple.[103]

    Partnerships (publicly known)Accenture[104] • Akbank[105] • American Express[106] • ATB Financial[107] • Axis Bank[105] • Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria (BBVA)[105] • BMO Financial Group[108] • Cambridge Global Payments[105] • Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CIBC)[107] • CBW Bank[41] • CGI Group[109] • Cross River Bank[41] • Davis + Henderson (D+H)[110] • Deloitte[111] • Earthport[42] • Expertus[112] • eZforex[105] • Fidor Bank[40] • Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group (MUFG)[105] • Mizuho Financial Group (MHFG)[108] • National Australia Bank (NAB)[108] • National Bank of Abu Dhabi (NBAD)[107] • ReiseBank[107] • Royal Bank of Canada (RBC)[108] • Santander[113] • SBI Holdings[114] • SBI Remit[105] • Shanghai Huarui Bank (SHRB)[108] • Siam Commercial Bank (SCB)[108] • Skandinaviska Enskilda Banken AB (SEB)[105] • Standard Chartered[108] • Star One Credit Union[105] • Tas Group[115] • Temenos Group[111] • UBS[107] • UniCredit Group[107] • Volante Technologies[116] • Westpac Banking Corp[108] • Yantra Financial Technologies[117] • Yes Bank[105]
    Experimenting (publicly known)Aeon Bank[118] • Aomori Bank[118] • Ashikaga Bank[118] • Australia and New Zealand Banking Group (ANZ)[119] • Awa Bank[118] • Bank of England[120] • Bank of the Ryukyus[118] • Bank of Yokohama[118] • Chiba Bank[118] • Chugoku Bank[118] • Commonwealth Bank of Australia[46] • Daiwa Next Bank[118] • DBS Group Holdings[121] • Fukui Bank[118] • Gunma Bank[118] • Hachijuni Bank[118] • Hiroshima Bank[118] • Hokuriku Bank[118] • Hyakugo Bank[118] • Iyo Bank[118] • Juroku Bank[118] • Keiyo Bank[118] • Michinoku Bank[118] • Mizuho Financial Group[118] • Musashino Bank[118] • Nishi-Nippon City Bank[118] • North Pacific Bank[118] • Oita Bank[118] • Orix Bank Corporation[118] • Resona Bank[118] • Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS)[122] • San-in Godo Bank[118] • SAP[123] • SBI Sumishin Net Bank[118] • Senshu Ikeda Bank[118] • Seven Bank[118] • Shimizu Bank[118] • Shinkin Central Bank[118] • Shinsei Bank[118] • Sikoku Bank[118] • Sony Bank[118] • Sumitomo Mitsui Trust Bank[118] • Suruga Bank[118] • The 77 Bank[118] • The Daishi Bank[118] • The Nomura Trust & Banking Co.[118] • Tochigi Bank[118] • Toho Bank[118] • Tokyo Star Bank[118] • Tsukuba Bank[118] • Western Union[33] • Yachiyo Bank[118] • Yamagata Bank[118] • Yamaguchi Bank[118]

    Reception

    Since its debut the Ripple protocol has received a fair amount of attention in both the financial and mainstream press. Ripple has recently been mentioned in industry articles by The Nielsen Company, the Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin, NACHA, and KPMG, with many of the articles examining Ripple's effect on internationalizing the banking industry.[124] In April 2015, American Banker asserted that "from banks' perspective, distributed ledgers like the Ripple system have a number of advantages over cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin."[13] Wrote the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, "the adoption of distributed networks, such as Ripple, may help the [banking] industry realize faster processing, as well as greater efficiencies for global payments and correspondent banking."[124] Writing for Esquire about Ripple as a payment network in 2013, Ken Kurson said that "the big financial-service brands ought to feel about Ripple the way the record labels felt about Napster."[125] The New York Times website Dealbook points out in 2014 that “[Ripple] is winning something that has proved elusive for virtual currencies: involvement from more mainstream players in the financial system.”[12] In August 2015, Ripple has been awarded as Technology Pioneer by World Economic Forum.[126]

    Comparisons with competition

    External video
    Ripple CEO Chris Larsen interviewed about Ripple by Deirdre Bolton on Bloomberg Television's Money Moves (2014)

    Though XRP is a third in market capitalization to bitcoin as a digital currency,[127] many members of the press have described Ripple as an up-and-coming rival to bitcoin. In late 2014, Bloomberg called bitcoin a "failing" digital currency, after bitcoin's currency fell 54 percent in value in one year. Ripple was described as a significant competitor, in part because of its real-time international money transfers.[128] Bill Gates supported this outlook and mentioned the Ripple system when asked about bitcoin in 2014, stating "there’s a lot that bitcoin or Ripple and variants can do to make moving money between countries easier and getting fees down pretty dramatically. But bitcoin won’t be the dominant system.”[129] About Ripple's allowance of any electronic value holder, the Vice President of the St. Louis Federal Reserve and professor at Simon Fraser University, David Andolfatto, stated in 2014 that "Ripple is a currency-agnostic protocol. Ripple is the winner. It processes anything."[130] For its creation and development of the Ripple protocol (RTXP) and the Ripple payment/exchange network, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) recognized Ripple Labs as one of 2014's 50 Smartest Companies in the February 2014 edition of MIT Technology Review.[131]

    Reactions to XRP

    The reaction to XRP is polarized in the crypto-currency community.[60] Proponents of bitcoin have criticized XRP for being "pre-mined," as XRP is built directly into the Ripple protocol and requires no mining. Also, Ripple Labs' distribution of the original limited amount of XRP currency has met with a fair amount of controversy,[71] and in particular the founders' retainment of 20% is seen as a high percentage. However, Esquire countered in 2013 that "if that is devious, then so is every company that's ever gone public while retaining the great bulk of its shares."[125] Much of the controversy was settled after the announcement that the founders[72] Jed McCaleb[132] and Arthur Britto[72] would be selling their XRP at a mediated rate over several years, "a move that should add stability and restore confidence to the XRP market."[72] CEO Chris Larsen in turn donated 7 billion XRP to the Ripple Foundation for Financial Innovation, with the XRP to be "locked up" and donated over time.[133] In 2016, of the 20% allocated initially to the founders, nearly half had been donated to non-profits and charities.[132][133][134]

    Ripple has also been criticized for not being truly decentralized, or for using only a few core validation nodes for transaction consensus, compared to Bitcoin and Ethereum in the five digits. Bitcoin developer Peter Todd notes, "..Ripple's technical documentation doesn't make any of these risks clear – nowhere do they describe in detail how nodes can fall out of consensus with one another if their UNLs (Unique Node List) don't match."[135]

    A scientific study made by two researchers from Stanford and Stockholm University that studied the money production from an energy consumption point of view and a macroeconomic level stated, "We would rather state that if there is trust (regardless of model enabling it),the main value driver behind this trusted asset is going to be its utility and scalability along with the costs associated with a further utilization and scaling of this asset. In this frame of reference Ripple's XRP is way ahead of its current competition. XRP is also in unique space where it's not built to replace current currencies but to work as a bridge currency where the systems upholding the current currencies can utilize Ripple's XRP for moving their native assets more efficiently and consequently costing less in terms of electricity, C02 emissions and cost less in any currency of your choice that you utilize with XRP."[136]

    See also

    Citations

    1. 1 2 3 "Official source code". Github. Retrieved May 14, 2014.
    2. 1 2 3 4 5 Buterin, Vitalik (September 26, 2013). "Ripple is officially open source". Bitcoin Magazine. Coin Publishing Ltd. Retrieved January 25, 2014.
    3. ↑ "Ripple Labs Banks $3.5M for Open-Source Payments System and Virtual Currency". The Wall Street Journal Pro. Dow Jones & Company. November 12, 2013. Retrieved January 28, 2014.
    4. 1 2 Bradbury, Danny (May 27, 2013). "Chris Larsen: Ripple is HTTP for money". CoinDesk. Coindesk Ltd. Retrieved January 26, 2014.
    5. 1 2 "Tech Showcase: Ripple Labs". Institute of International Finance.
    6. ↑ "Home". XRP Ledger Dev Portal. Retrieved 24 Aug 2018.
    7. ↑ "First Bitcoin, now Google-backed OpenCoin: a new disintermediation threat for banks". Retrieved August 17, 2017.
    8. ↑ "Ripple Unveils Strategy to 'Become More Decentralized than Bitcoin'". Retrieved August 17, 2017.
    9. ↑ "Ripple's Distributed Ledger Network Passes 50-Validator Milestone". Retrieved August 19, 2017.
    10. ↑ Geron, Tomio (2018-09-24). "Ripple Co-Founder's Token Selloff Accelerates". Wall Street Journal. ISSN 0099-9660. Retrieved 2018-09-26.
    11. ↑ Rise of Bitcoin Competitor Ripple Creates Wealth to Rival Zuckerberg
    12. 1 2 Popper, Nathaniel. "The rush to coin virtual money with real value". The New York Times. The New York Times Company. Retrieved January 26, 2014.
    13. 1 2 Todd, Sarah (April 7, 2015). "Banks Can Cherry-Pick the Best Bits from Bitcoin: Report". American Banker. Retrieved 2015-06-16.
    14. 1 2 3 4 5 Buterin, Vitalik (February 26, 2013). "Introducing Ripple". Bitcoin Magazine. Retrieved February 6, 2014.
    15. ↑ Deng, Xiaotie; Graham, Fan Chung, eds. (November 29, 2007). Internet and Network Economics: Third International Workshop, WINE 2007, Proceedings. Germany: Springer. p. 268. ISBN 978-3-540-77104-3.
    16. 1 2 3 4 Peck, Morgan (January 14, 2013). "Ripple Could Help or Harm Bitcoin". IEEE Spectrum. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers. Retrieved January 27, 2014.
    17. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Reutzel, Bailey. "Disruptor Chris Larsen Returns with a Bitcoin-Like Payments System". PaymentSource. Retrieved 18 March 2014.
    18. ↑ Liu, Alec. "Ripple Could Make Bitcoin Great (or Destroy It)". Motherboard. Archived from the original on February 7, 2014. Retrieved January 27, 2014.
    19. 1 2 3 Grant, Rebecca (April 11, 2013). "OpenCoin raises seed round so 'anyone in the world can trade any amount of money in any currency'". VentureBeat. Retrieved February 6, 2014.
    20. ↑ Craig, Michael (February 5, 2015). "The Race to Replace Bitcoin". Observer. Retrieved 2015-06-13.
    21. 1 2 "Company Overview of Ripple Labs Inc". Bloomberg. Retrieved January 27, 2014.
    22. 1 2 3 4 5 Andrews, Edmund L. (September 24, 2013). "Chris Larsen: Money Without Borders". Stanford Graduate School of Business. Retrieved 2015-04-10.
    23. ↑ Bala, Dr. Venkatesh (October 8, 2014). "Lessons in Innovation Leadership: Chris Larsen". Nielsen. The Cambridge Group. Retrieved 2015-06-10.
    24. 1 2 3 Perry, John-David (December 5, 2014). "The Future for Global Value Transfers". Fox Business. Retrieved 2015-06-16.
    25. ↑ Lashinsky, Adam (August 22, 2014). "Isn't one Internet enough?". Fortune Magazine. Retrieved 2015-04-10.
    26. ↑ Shirley, Siluk. "Google Ventures invests in Bitcoin competitor OpenCoin". CoinDesk. Retrieved 18 March 2014.
    27. 1 2 3 4 "FinCEN Fines Ripple Labs Inc. in First Civil Enforcement" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on May 12, 2015.
    28. ↑ "OpenCoin Extends Ripple Network to Include All Bitcoin Merchants and Users". Yahoo Finance. Retrieved 18 March 2014.
    29. 1 2 David, Gilson. "OpenCoin: Ripple users can send payments to bitcoin addresses". CoinDesk. Retrieved March 17, 2014.
    30. ↑ Kharif, Olga. "Ripple Takes on Western Union With Deal to Grow Payments". Bloomberg. Retrieved January 28, 2014.
    31. ↑ "The Future of Money and Bitcoin by Chris Larsen, CEO of OpenCoin". Retrieved February 24, 2015.
    32. 1 2 Cooper, Jane (March 11, 2014). "Ripple Labs CEO looks to revolutionise online payments". The Banker. Retrieved 2015-04-10.
    33. 1 2 3 Ryan, Philip (April 29, 2015). "Western Union Will Give Ripple a Chance". Bank Innovation. Retrieved 2015-06-09.
    34. 1 2 Bradbury, Danny. "Ripple Courts Developers, Entrepreneurs With New Initiatives". CoinDesk. Retrieved 18 March 2014.
    35. ↑ "Introducing Ripple Client: the iOS App". Ripple blog. Ripple Labs Inc. Archived from the original on April 1, 2014.
    36. ↑ Kirk, Jeremy. "Apple removes Blockchain, last Bitcoin wallet app, from iOS App Store". PCWorld. Retrieved 18 March 2014.
    37. ↑ Download the Ripple Client - Official site Archived June 4, 2015, at the Wayback Machine.
    38. ↑ Cawrey, Daniel (July 21, 2014). "Ripple Labs Unveils Proposal for New Smart Contract System". coindesk. Retrieved 2015-06-09.
    39. ↑ Scully, Matt (September 24, 2014). "Alternative Money Mover Ripple Labs Enters U.S. Banking System". American Banker. Retrieved 2015-06-16.
    40. 1 2 Bannister, David (September 30, 2014). "Next out of the block". Banking Technology. Retrieved 2015-06-09.
    41. 1 2 3 Carson, Biz (September 24, 2014). "Two US banks are ready to embrace the Ripple protocol". Gigaom. Retrieved June 9, 2015.
    42. 1 2 Paul Vigna, Michael Casey (December 4, 2014). "BitBeat: Ripple Partners With Global Payments Service Earthport". Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 2015-06-09.
    43. ↑ Wilmoth, Josiah (December 13, 2014). "XRP price rise gives Ripple $500 million market cap". CryptoCoinNews. Retrieved 2015-06-09.
    44. ↑ "Ripple's 53% Surge Makes It the Second-Biggest Cryptocurrency". Bloomberg.
    45. ↑ Reutzel, Bailey (February 23, 2015). "Digital-Only German Bank to Enter U.S. Market, Court Millennials". American Banker. Retrieved 2015-06-09.
    46. 1 2 Riley, Duncan (June 1, 2015). "CBA signs deal with Ripple for Blockchain settlements, may eventually support Bitcoin". Silicon Angle. Retrieved 2015-06-09.
    47. ↑ Merrett, Rebecca (May 27, 2015). "Commonwealth Bank to launch Ripple payments between its subsidiaries". CIO. Retrieved 2015-06-05.
    48. ↑ Higgins, Stan (November 3, 2014). "Money20/20 Day 1: Regulators, Finance Giants Forecast Bitcoin's Future". CoinDesk. Retrieved 2015-06-09.
    49. 1 2 "What Ripple's Fincen Fine Means for the Digital Currency Industry". American Banker. May 6, 2015. Retrieved 2015-06-09.
    50. ↑ "Ripple receives BitLicense". Retrieved June 20, 2016.
    51. ↑ "Japanese bank consortium to build new payments network with SBI Ripple Asia". Retrieved August 24, 2016.
    52. ↑ "Official Launch of "The Japan Bank Consortium to Central Provide Domestic and Cross-border Payment"" (PDF). Retrieved July 12, 2017.
    53. ↑ Yoshikawa, Emi (July 10, 2017). "Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation and Japan Post Bank Join SBI Ripple Asia's Bank Consortium". ripple.com.
    54. ↑ "Major Banks Launch Global Payments Steering Group". Retrieved September 23, 2016.
    55. ↑ "MUFG Joins Ripple's Interbank Group for Global Payments Based on Distributed Financial Technology" (PDF). Retrieved April 2, 2017.
    56. ↑ Irrera, Anna (2018-09-19). "Blockchain startup Ripple signs up PNC as a customer for its payment tech". Reuters U.K. Retrieved 2018-09-21.
    57. 1 2 Aranda, Daniel; Zagone, Ryan (May 1, 2015). "The 'Ripple' Effect: Why an Open Payments Infrastructure Matters". Consultative Group to Assist the Poor.
    58. 1 2 3 "Executive Summary for Financial Institutions". ripple.com. Retrieved 2015-06-16.
    59. ↑ Katakam, Arunjay (September 4, 2014). "The evolution of cross-border transfers: new infrastructure for MNO's to increase remittance". GSMA. Archived from the original on June 18, 2015. Retrieved June 16, 2015.
    60. 1 2 3 Liu, Alec. "Beyond Bitcoin: a Guide to the Most Promising Cryptocurrencies". Motherboard (beta) blogs. Vice Media Inc. Archived from the original on December 24, 2013.
    61. 1 2 Trach, Alina (May 27, 2015). "Ripple Trade to Implement Identity Verification Procedures". ripple.com. Retrieved 2015-06-05.
    62. ↑ "Ripple Explained: Medieval Banking with a Digital Twist".
    63. ↑ "Trade Volume". ripple.com. Retrieved 2016-09-15.
    64. 1 2 John, Light. "Decentralized Exchange for Fun and Profit". Let's Talk Bitcoin. Retrieved January 26, 2014.
    65. ↑ Tong, Anna. "Understanding trust lines". Ripple Labs. Archived from the original on February 1, 2014. Retrieved February 2, 2014.
    66. 1 2 "Ripple Gateways". IRBA. Retrieved January 27, 2014.
    67. 1 2 "Public Disclosure Standards". International Ripple Business Association. Retrieved May 14, 2014.
    68. ↑ "International Ripple Business Association". ZoomInfo. Retrieved May 14, 2014.
    69. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Britto, Arthur. "The Ripple Ledger Consensus Process". ripple.com. Retrieved 2015-05-09.
    70. ↑ "The Science of Trust".
    71. 1 2 3 Pick, Leon (April 23, 2015). "Ripple orders freeze". Finance Magnates. Retrieved 2015-06-09.
    72. 1 2 3 4 Carney, Michael (August 15, 2014). "Ripple settles with estranged founder Jed McCaleb, outlining a metered sale of his XRP holdings". Pando.com. Retrieved 2015-06-09.
    73. 1 2 3 "Safety, liveness and fault tolerance—the consensus choices".
    74. 1 2 "Stellar Network Fork Prompts Concerns Over Ripple Consensus Protocol".
    75. ↑ Thomas, Stefan (December 7, 2014). "Why the Stellar Forking Issue Does Not Affect Ripple". ripple.com. Retrieved 2015-06-05.
    76. 1 2 "Payment Network". Ripple Labs. Archived from the original on December 15, 2013. Retrieved February 2, 2014.
    77. ↑ Simonite, Tom (April 11, 2013). "Big-name investors back effort to build a better Bitcoin". MIT Technology Review. Retrieved January 26, 2014.
    78. ↑ Schwartz, Ariel. "Bitcoin 2.0: Can Ripple Make Digital Currency Mainstream?". Fast Company. Retrieved February 2, 2014.
    79. 1 2 McGarvey, Robert. "'Ripple' is the New Bitcoin: Adventures in Virtual Currency". The Street. Archived from the original on October 29, 2013. Retrieved February 2, 2014.
    80. ↑ Bradbury, Danny. "Chris Larsen: Ripple is HTTP for money". CoinDesk. Retrieved February 2, 2014.
    81. 1 2 "Bridge Currency". ripple.com. Archived from the original on May 12, 2015. Retrieved June 16, 2015.
    82. ↑ "Grid". RippleCharts. Archived from the original on February 10, 2014. Retrieved January 27, 2014.
    83. ↑ "Company Summary". Peercover. Archived from the original on January 27, 2014. Retrieved January 27, 2014.
    84. ↑ Southurst, Jon. "Bullion Exchange Brings Ripple into the Physical World". CoinDesk. Retrieved February 2, 2014.
    85. ↑ Bailey, Reutzel. "Ripple Network Adds Currency Conversion for Bitcoin Payments". PaymentsSource. Retrieved March 17, 2014.
    86. ↑ "What an Open Network Means for Banks, Market Makers and Regulators". ripple.com. Retrieved May 17, 2016.
    87. ↑ "Market Makers". ripple.com. October 16, 2014. Archived from the original on December 19, 2014. Retrieved June 16, 2015.
    88. 1 2 3 Spaven, Emily. "Online payment network Ripple Labs receives $3.5m in new funding". CoinDesk. Retrieved January 27, 2014.
    89. 1 2 3 "Math Based Currency". ripple.com. Archived from the original on March 30, 2015. Retrieved June 16, 2015.
    90. ↑ "Ripple". Github. Retrieved January 28, 2014.
    91. 1 2 3 4 "XRP Distribution". Ripple Labs. Retrieved February 24, 2015.
    92. 1 2 "Proposed change to Ripple reserve requirement". Ripple blog. Ripple Labs Inc.
    93. 1 2 3 "Crypto-Currency Market Capitalizations". coinmarketcap.com. Retrieved October 3, 2016.
    94. ↑ "Cryptocurrency Market Capitalizations". CoinMarketCap. Retrieved 2018-01-27. , including all (1132) cryptocurrencies with known market capitalization.
    95. 1 2 Garlinghouse, Brad (May 16, 2017). "Ripple to Place 55 Billion XRP in Escrow to Ensure Certainty of Total XRP Supply". ripple.com.
    96. ↑ "Ripple Forum • View topic - [OFFICIAL] We're moving the giveaway out of beta". Retrieved February 24, 2015.
    97. ↑ "XRP Distribution". Ripple Labs website. Ripple Labs Inc.
    98. ↑ Pilkington, Nicholas (June 25, 2017). "Investing in Ripple: The Next Big Thing?". themarketmogul.com.
    99. ↑ "Network Feed". Ripple Labs. Retrieved January 28, 2014.
    100. ↑ King, Steve. "Missed Bitcoin? No Worries". Netswitch Technology Management. Retrieved January 27, 2014.
    101. ↑ Liu, Alec (April 27, 2015). "rippled Feature Update: NuDB and Autobridging". Ripple blog. Retrieved 2015-06-16.
    102. ↑ Teague, Solomon. "First Bitcoin, now Google-backed Open Coin". EuroMoney. Retrieved February 2, 2014.
    103. ↑ Del Castillo, Michael (2016-09-23). "Global Banks Partner to Form Blockchain Payments Network". CoinDesk. Retrieved 2018-02-28.
    104. ↑ "Payments platform Ripple inks deal with Accenture". Retrieved June 30, 2016.
    105. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 "Blockchain payments firm Ripple signs up 10 more banks and PSPs". Retrieved April 26, 2017.
    106. ↑ "Coming in 2017: "Live" Blockchain Deployments Promise to Accelerate Payment Processing Services and Trade Finance". Coming in 2017: “Live” Blockchain Deployments Promise to Accelerate Payment Processing Services and Trade Finance. Retrieved 2017-12-18.
    107. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "Seven Leading Banks Join Ripple's Global Network". Retrieved June 24, 2016.
    108. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 "Several Global Banks Join Ripple's Growing Network". Retrieved September 15, 2016.
    109. ↑ "CGI adds Ripple gateway to payments portfolio". Retrieved June 10, 2016.
    110. ↑ "D+H adopts Ripple distributed ledger to reduce costs". Retrieved June 10, 2016.
    111. 1 2 "Ripple and Temenos power Deloitte's payments project". Retrieved June 10, 2016.
    112. ↑ "Expertus Adds Blockchain to its Global Payment Hub Offering" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on August 21, 2016. Retrieved November 8, 2016.
    113. ↑ "Santander taps Ripple blockchain tech for international payments app". Retrieved June 10, 2016.
    114. ↑ "Japan's SBI Holdings Teams With Ripple to Launch New Company". Retrieved June 10, 2016.
    115. ↑ "Real-time cross-border funds settlement for financial service businesses". Retrieved June 10, 2016.
    116. ↑ "Volante launches a "plug and play" Ripple integration solution". Retrieved June 10, 2016.
    117. ↑ "Yantra Financial Technologies Integrates Ripple Protocol Into Latest Risk Management System". Retrieved June 29, 2016.
    118. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 "Announcing the Successful Completion of RC Cloud Pilot By Japan Bank Consortium" (PDF). Retrieved March 20, 2017.
    119. ↑ "Westpac, ANZ trial Ripple's Blockchain ledger system, but say no to Bitcoin, for now". Retrieved June 10, 2016.
    120. ↑ "Bank of England trials artificial intelligence and blockchain in bid to stay ahead of the pack". Retrieved March 20, 2017.
    121. ↑ "StanChart, DBS's Trade Finance Distributed Ledger: How It Works". Retrieved June 10, 2016.
    122. ↑ "RBS Trials Ripple as Part of £3.5 Billion Tech Revamp". Retrieved June 10, 2016.
    123. ↑ "Threat of Blockchain Prompts New Strategy for Germany's SAP". Retrieved August 18, 2016.
    124. 1 2 "Industry Perspectives: Ripple Inclusions". ripple.com. Retrieved 2015-06-16.
    125. 1 2 Kurson, Ken (November 27, 2013). "The true value of Bitcoin and Ripple". Esquire Blogs. Hearst Communications, Inc. Retrieved January 26, 2014.
    126. ↑ "Ripple Labs Awarded as Technology Pioneer by World Economic Forum". Retrieved June 30, 2016.
    127. ↑ "Ripple becomes second most valuable crypto-coin". Retrieved January 2, 2018.
    128. ↑ Kharif, Olga (December 15, 2014). "Bitcoin Bears Say Told-You-So as Digital Currency Falls". Bloomberg. Retrieved 2015-06-16.
    129. ↑ Higgins, Stan (January 22, 2015). "Bill Gates: Bitcoin Alone Won't Solve Global Payments Challenges". CoinDesk. Retrieved 2015-06-16.
    130. ↑ Cawrey, Daniel. "Federal Bank VP: Bitcoin Threat Means Banks Must 'Adapt or Die'". CoinDesk. Retrieved May 14, 2014.
    131. ↑ Bergstein, Brian. "50 Smartest Companies". MIT Technology Review. Retrieved March 12, 2014.
    132. 1 2 Long, Monica (February 11, 2016). "Final Settlement with Jed". Official Ripple Forum. Retrieved 2016-11-06.
    133. 1 2 Long, Monica (April 23, 2015). "RippleWorks (Chris Larsen's foundation) launches". Official Ripple Forum. Retrieved 2016-11-06.
    134. ↑ "Ripple Creator Donates $500k in XRP to Artificial Intelligence Research Charity". Retrieved November 6, 2016.
    135. ↑ "$100 Billion Controversy: XRP's Surge Raises Hard Questions for Ripple". CoinDesk. January 4, 2018.
    136. ↑ Leopold, Sid John; Englesson, Niclas (November 27, 2017). "How Eco friendly is our money and is there an alternative?" (PDF). Retrieved August 27, 2018.
    This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.