Seventeen Seconds

At the end of the Cure's 1979 UK tour supporting Siouxsie and the Banshees, Robert Smith spoke less and less with bassist Michael Dempsey. An early version of "M" had been performed at a few concerts, but Dempsey did not like the new musical direction that Smith wanted to take. Smith commented: "I think the final straw came when I played Michael the demos for the next album and he hated them. He wanted us to be XTC part 2 and – if anything – I wanted us to be the Banshees part 2. So he left".[1] Playing guitar with the Banshees for two months and learning their songs opened up another horizon to Smith. "It allowed me to think beyond what we were doing. I wanted to have a band that does what Steven Severin and Budgie do, where they just get a bassline and the drum part and Siouxsie wails".[2] The records to which Smith was frequently listening during the composition of the album were Five Leaves Left by Nick Drake, Isle of Wight by Jimi Hendrix, Astral Weeks by Van Morrison and Low by David Bowie.[1] Smith wrote the lyrics and music for most of the record at his parents' home, on a Hammond organ with a built-in tape recorder. Interviewed in 2004, producer Mike Hedges did not recall any demo tracks, with the band generally playing the track in the studio before laying down a backing track to which overdubs were added.[3]

Two members of the Magazine Spies, bass guitarist Simon Gallup and keyboardist Matthieu Hartley, were added to the band's lineup.[4] Gallup replaced Dempsey, which relieved Smith as he felt Dempsey's basslines were too ornate. Hartley's synth work added a new dimension to the band's newly ethereal sound, although he would later clash with Smith over complexity; Hartley enjoyed complex chords but Smith wanted single notes.[3]

Because of financial restraints, the album was recorded and mixed in seven days on a budget of between £2,000 and £3,000, which resulted in the band working 16 or 17 hours a day.[3] Smith stated that as a result, the track "The Final Sound", which was planned to be much longer, was cut down to 53 seconds because the tape ran out while recording and band could not record it again. The album, mostly a collection of downbeat tracks, features ambient echoing vocals [5] with the sonic direction driven by its drum sound.[3]

Retrospectively, Seventeen Seconds has been considered an early example of gothic rock.[6][7] Its "gloomscapes" are considered to be "a sonic touchstone" for the forthcoming movement.[7] The track "The Final Sound" is "so positively gothic you could almost be fooled into believing that it was lifted from the soundtrack of some Hammer horror gorefest".[7] The album has also been described as new wave.[8]

Seventeen Seconds was released on 22 April 1980. It reached No. 20 on the British album charts.[3] The record was repackaged in the US in 1981 (on the A&M label) with Faith as Happily Ever After, available as a double LP. In 2005, the album was remastered as part of Universal's Deluxe Edition series, featuring bonus live tracks and demos as well as studio material by Cult Hero, a 1970s-style progressive rock band along the lines of Easy Cure that featured Smith's postman Frank Bell as lead singer.

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[9]
Blender	[10]
Encyclopedia of Popular Music	[11]
Entertainment Weekly	B[12]
The Guardian	[13]
Mojo	[14]
Pitchfork	7.5/10[5]
The Rolling Stone Album Guide	[15]
Sounds	[16]
Uncut	[17]

The album's songs are described by critics as featuring vague, often unsettling lyrics and dark, spare, minimalistic melodies. Some reviewers, such as Nick Kent of NME, felt that Seventeen Seconds represented a far more mature Cure, who had come very far musically in less than one year.[18] The album was lauded by some critics and panned as a "collection of soundtracks" by another. Chris Westwood of Record Mirror described the album as "sad Cure, sitting in cold rooms, watching clocks."[19]

Simon Reynolds said the album was "translucent-sounding", with shades of the Durutti Column, Young Marble Giants and Another Green World by Brian Eno.[20]

Seventeen Seconds is in the book 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die.[21] The authors note: "Like the album's cover art, which is little more than an abstract blur, the bleak, minimalist sound of Seventeen Seconds-era Cure is subtly suggestive." Attention is drawn to the "beguiling bleakness, both in its brief instrumentals and the more pop-oriented tracks (such as the sharp, hook-laden 'Play for Today') that hark back to their earlier work."[22]

All lyrics are written by Robert Smith; all music is composed by The Cure (Smith, Matthieu Hartley, Simon Gallup and Lol Tolhurst).

Note

• The US cassette version has "A Forest" on Side A and "Play for Today" on Side B. Also, the artwork is different, with some tree branches at left and a reddish blob at the bottom.

The Cure

• Robert Smith – guitars, vocals, production
• Matthieu Hartley – keyboards
• Lol Tolhurst – drums
• Simon Gallup – bass guitar

Production

• Mike Hedges – production, engineering
• Chris Parry – production
• David Kemp – engineering
• Martyn Webster – engineering assistance

• Seventeen Seconds (Adobe Flash) at Radio3Net (streamed copy where licensed)
• Seventeen Seconds at Discogs (list of releases)