Late Registration

Late Registration is the second of West's planned four education-themed studio albums.[1] Following the major success of The College Dropout, the album reveals his progression in writing lyrics and an incorporation of a wider range of musical styles.[2] At the time, the focal point of West's production style was the use of sped-up vocal samples from soul records.[2] However, due in part to the acclaim of The College Dropout, such sampling had been much copied by others; with that overuse, and also because West felt he had become too dependent on the technique, he decided to find a new sound.[1]

West collaborated with American film score composer Jon Brion, who served as the album's co-executive producer for several tracks.[3] West had been exposed to Brion's work while watching the film Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, for which Brion had composed music. West was also listening to songs Brion had produced for When the Pawn..., the second studio album of alternative singer-songwriter Fiona Apple, another one of West's favorite musicians and sources of musical inspiration for the album;[3][4] West described his direction as "that Coldplay, Portishead, Fiona Apple style".[2] Although Brion had no prior experience in creating hip-hop records, he and West found that they could productively work together after their first afternoon in the studio where they discovered that neither confined his musical knowledge and vision to one specific genre.[5] When questioned if his presence made Late Registration any less hip-hop, Brion replied, "There are colors and ideas that make [the album] different from average hip-hop, but Kanye is already different from the average hip-hop guy. He's got this sense of pop record-making which is really solid, and he likes tracks with a lot of things going on in them – which is not necessarily common for hip-hop. He was already barking up that tree. This is definitely not just a hip-hop album. But it is also by no means overtly arty, or non-hip-hop. I don't think it's a weird record by any means."[3]

Film composer Jon Brion assisted with the album's production.

West took over a year and invested two million dollars towards the construction of Late Registration.[6] The majority of the recording sessions for the album took place at Sony Music Studios in New York City and at the Record Plant in Hollywood, California; other sessions took place at Chalice Recording Studios and Grandmaster Recording Studios in Hollywood.[7] He began working in the studio after he finished touring with Usher on the R&B singer's The Truth Tour.[8] By November 2004, West had completed nearly seventy-five percent of the album.[9] However he felt unsatisfied with its outcome and in March of the following year, he brought in Jon Brion, which drastically altered the project's direction.[3]

The album's recording sessions between West and Brion were largely exploratory, with the two experimenting with a broad spectrum of sounds. West would construct a song's basic structure, bringing in samples, drum beat programming and occasionally unfinished rap verses.[1] After brainstorming over the musical direction the album could go, he would then select from a variety of unique instruments that Brion provided (and played) and attempt to incorporate their distinctive sound into the song's texture.[3][10] West envisioned the album as like the creation of a film: visualizing the songs as scenes, outlining each in such a way that they efficiently conveyed their respective social or introspective context, and ensuring that all synchronized within the fabric of the complete set.[1] This sentiment was shared by Jon Brion who said, "He thinks in frequency ranges. I can recognize when someone sees music architecturally, which is how I work. I see it as a spatial thing: left to right, front to back, up and down. It's animated and it's moving in real time. Kanye has that. He tries things out until it fits, until it sits where it is supposed to sit and everything has the correct emotional function. He has real instincts like any great record-maker."[10]

For Late Registration, West also collaborated with guest artists, whom he selected based on the effect each of their voices had on him when he heard them. He cited the serene vocals of Adam Levine, the trademark sound of Brandy, the rap skills of Jay-Z and the lyricism of Paul Wall as primary examples.[11] Adam Levine, lead vocalist of pop rock band Maroon 5 is featured on the album's opening track, "Heard 'Em Say." The two had previously collaborated when Maroon 5 commissioned West to produce a remix for "This Love" and later developed a friendship while sitting together on a flight to Rome for the 2004 MTV Europe Music Awards.[12] While playing songs from his second album on his iPod for him during the flight, West came across the demo for "Heard 'Em Say" to which Levine added a R&B hook he had recently written and thought was perfect for it.[12] The track was recorded quickly after the 2005 Grammy Awards ceremony, as Levine only had a couple of free hours available for time in the studio, and Brion was able to translate the two compositions in a matter of hours.[3]

West originally produced and recorded "Gold Digger" in Ludacris's home in Atlanta, Georgia for Shawnna's 2004 debut album Worth tha Weight and had written the chorus from a female first-person viewpoint. However, Shawnna passed on the song. West rewrote the two verses from a male's point-of-view for himself; about a year later, just before "Gold Digger" was set to be released, adding a third verse, recording and mastering it at Sony Music Studios in New York in a week.[13] After he went with friend John Mayer to see Foxx's portrayal of Ray Charles in the 2004 film Ray, West decided to have Foxx sing an interpolation of Charles' song "I Got a Woman" in place of the original sample.[13] Once the track was in place, it was layered with additional instruments provided by Brion and individually selected by West.[13]

Houston-based rapper Paul Wall appears alongside West and his GOOD Music label-mate GLC on "Drive Slow", which was recorded in Los Angeles after the two had met while posing for a photo shoot in an August issue of King in a spread titled "Coming Kings".[14] West had originally wanted Sri Lankan rapper M.I.A. to appear on the track, but she opted out of the appearance due to a busy schedule.[15][16] "My Way Home" is performed by West's close friend and GOOD Music associate Common, whose sixth studio album Be was being produced and recorded by West simultaneously with Late Registration. Certain tracks West originally crafted for Be that Common passed on subsequently ended up on his second album.[17]

While the original version of "Diamonds from Sierra Leone" featured West as the sole performer, he decided to record a remix to the song which included guest verse provided by Jay-Z—who had come out of retirement from rapping—after learning of the civil war in Sierra Leone financed by conflict diamonds.[18] Both the original and remix versions of "Diamond from Sierra Leone" appear on the album, with the former included as a bonus track. The song contains live drums played by Michel Gondry, the director of Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind and later the first music video for "Heard 'Em Say", who had visited the studio on a day Brion set up a drum kit.[3][12] According to Jay-Z, West mixed "Diamonds from Sierra Leone" about fourteen times before he felt comfortable to release it as the album's lead single.[19] The recording also experienced delay when West and Brion were required to wait two weeks to rent the harpsichord that they used for percussion on the song.[20]

West recorded a verse by rap artist Nas—one of his idol rappers—for the track "We Major" without informing Jay-Z, who at the time was engaged in a feud with Nas.[21] GOOD, music label-mate Really Doe also appears on the track, delivering its elongated chorus. West later revealed that part of the reason he created the song was to dismantle the feud between the MCs, which they did later that year.[21] "Hey Mama", dedicated to his mother Donda West,[2] was first recorded by West as early as 2000.[22] Brion ran into some obstruction while conducting a twenty-piece orchestra for "Celebration", as its musicians found themselves giggling at West's humorous lyrics which hampered their playing.[3] On "Roses," West and Brion had some minor discord; Brion initially layered it with keyboard arrangements, only for West to remove his keys along with the beat and completely reconfigure the entire song in such a way that its verses are built around the rhythm formed by his vocals and Brion's arrangements arrive during the choruses. Brion later lightheartedly compared the indecision surrounding the construction of the track to that of Prince's famous last-minute removal of the bassline from "When Doves Cry."[3] According to Patti LaBelle, she contributed vocals to "Roses". "I was in his studio one night, and [West] and his mother both asked if I'd just sing something on this song", Labelle recalled. "I didn't get a credit on the album because the liner notes had already been printed up."[23]

The album's music blends West's primary soulful hip hop production with Brion's elaborate chamber pop orchestration, and experimentally delves into a wide array of different genres, including jazz, blues, rock, R&B, spoken word, funk, turntablism, western classical, and psychedelic soul.[2] With the presence of Brion, who conducts a twenty-piece orchestra and plays instruments individually selected by West, the album is largely orchestral in nature, brandishing a euphony of string arrangements, piano chords, brass flecks, and horn riffs among other symphonic instrumentation.[3] They also incorporated a myriad of foreign and vintage instruments not typical in popular music, let alone hip hop, such as a celesta,[25] harpsichord, Chamberlin,[26] CS-80 analog synthesizer, Chinese bells and berimbau.[27]

For Late Registration, Serena Kim of Vibe magazine took note of how West uses unconventional styles and sudden musical shifts in song structures, drawing comparisons to The Beatles during their experimental era.[28] Rolling Stone described Late Registration as West claiming "the whole world of music as hip-hop turf" chronicling the album as "his mad quest to explode every cliché about hip-hop identity."[2] Kim concurred with this sentiment, stating, "West ambitiously attempts to depart from the street sensibilities of Dropout by giving Late Registration a shiny, quasi-alt-pop finish."[28] The album has also been described as a work of pop rap, by journalists Caleb Wossen of the Dallas Observer[29] and Vice magazine's Eric Sundermann.[30]

The album's opening track "Heard 'Em Say" exhibits a cascading piano melody provided by excerpts of "Someone That I Used To Love" as performed by Natalie Cole embellished over tumbling beats and a bass synthesizer as well as acoustic guitar.[31] The song's intricately composed outro, with the right amount of flourish provided by new musical elements such as xylophones and bells,[32] exemplifies the musical complexity of the album as a whole. "Touch the Sky" stands as the sole song on the entire album not to feature production by West. The song was produced by fellow Roc-a-Fella producer Just Blaze, who uses a slowed-down sample of Curtis Mayfield's "Move On Up" filled with jubilant Latin horn blares.[33][34] "Gold Digger" contains an interpolation of "I Got a Woman" by Ray Charles and a bouncy beat formed from handclaps as well as scratches by West's touring DJ A-Trak.[7] Towards the end, the song employs vintage synthesizers,[35] which emit a honking sound[36] in cadence to Kanye's voice.[37] West's production approach comes full circle within "Drive Slow", a song that samples the alto sax[38] from Hank Crawford's recording of "Wildflower", while also slightly speeding up and looping the song's intro melody over a jazzy downtempo drum loop[39] before slowing down the track towards the end of the song, which is antithetical to West's Chipmunk-styled loops.[40]

The interlude "My Way Home" contains a sample of "Home is Where the Hatred Is" by Gil Scott-Heron.[7] This facet is accentuated by Common's performance, which pays homage to the poet by the delivering its single verse in a distinctive proto-rap manner reminiscent of Scott-Heron's influential vocal style. "Crack Music" is sparsely built on incessant snare drum hits and clipped horn blares. The track sees an ephemeral return of West's old production attributes, as it possesses a syncopated martial beat, gospel choir symphony, and a spoken word passage within its coda. The poetic "Roses" is partially a cappella in structure, displaying verses rapped over sparse keyboards and a slowed rhythm with the music arriving at the chorus, which features additional vocals, trumpet riffs, electric guitar phrasings, and finally a vocal and piano sample from Bill Withers' "Rosie". "Bring Me Down" carries a bombast dramatic air, as it holds more orchestration than any other track on Late Registration.[7] Additionally, it features an overdubbing of Brandy's vocals to create a chorus effect, a recording technique in which her lone voice produces the illusion of a 48-voice Choir[41] singing harmonies. The up-tempo arrangement of "Addiction" contains synths, congas,[34] filtered Hi-hats, a guitar and a sampled line from "My Funny Valentine" as performed by Etta James.[42] All the while, West's overdubbed vocals reverbs in and out of the track.[43] For "Diamonds from Sierra Leone", West used a music sample of the theme song for the 1971 James Bond film, Diamonds Are Forever as performed by Shirley Bassey and layered it with lush arrangements[37] featuring instruments such as live drums,[7] horns, strings[34] and a harpsichord[44] that all build in intensity with his voice.[37]

Late Registration's longest track, the seven-minute-long "We Major", implements exuberant, amplified backing vocals and a "splashy disco groove" featuring a bassline, electric piano Glissandos[40] and horns.[45] The melody of "Hey Mama" is laced with a folksy looped "La-la-la" vocal sample[2] from "Today Won't Come Again" by Donal Leace, while its beat is produced by Tin Pan Alley-styled Drums. Additionally, it contains vocoder-processed background vocals, a xylophone solo and a cascading synth outro.[46] "Celebration", opening with an electronic twinkling sound,[3] contains samples of "Heavenly Dream" by The KayGees.[7] A columnist for The Guardian described it as evoking "the lavish 1970s psychedelic soul of Rotary Connection."[35] Some of the most elaborate orchestral arrangement expressed on the entire album is contained within its closing track "Gone." The composition begins with a vocal sample of "It's Too Late" by Otis Redding and a two-chord piano ostinato, followed by a simplistic funk beat. As the song progresses, its structure gradually morphs and develops more and more musicality. Over time, the composition assumes ten violins, four violas and four cellos in the midst of verses, all of which initially come in brief staccato bursts that simply punctuate the rhythm but eventually expand and consolidate into a fully formed string section by the arrival of the harmonic choruses. After its third verse, the song enters an instrumental passage before returning with a fourth verse from West, where the rise and fall of his voice is intricately emulated by the fluctuation of the string orchestra.[36]

West and Foxx collaborated on the track "Gold Digger".

According to Josh Tyrangiel of Time magazine, Late Registration serves as an exhibition of "the stealthy power of West's storytelling."[47] West stated that his goal for the album was to touch on topics that people from all walks of life could find relatable, while remaining true to himself: "[I wanted to have] raps that were just as ill as Jadakiss and just as understandable as Will Smith."[11] The opening track "Heard 'Em Say" is a "mournfully contemplative" song that "talks about being honest with yourself in a world that is not." The song is written from the perspective of an afflicted, impoverished American quietly lamenting the fallacies of society and questioning the ways of the world around him.[48] West delivers a tongue-in-cheek lyrical narrative within "Gold Digger" in which he critically depicts the disastrous life of a man married to a woman who manipulates him for financial gain. However, another story arises within the third verse, which illustrates a once destitute black male who earns a fortune and decides to leave a loyal, unselfish girlfriend for a white woman.[24]

"Crack Music" continues the avenue of socio-political commentary initiated within "Heard 'Em Say." However, two songs express polar opposite tones; where "Heard 'Em Say" was self-effacing and passive-aggressive, "Crack Music" is audacious and straightforward.[11] In the song, West dually discusses the spread and devastating impact of crack cocaine in black communities and champions the sovereignty of music pioneered by black musicians, metaphorically equating their contrarily addictive power and influence on American society.[11] On the sentimental "Roses", Kanye gives a firsthand account of the hospitalization of his ailing grandmother within a melancholic poem to produce a critique of the healthcare system.[2]

The original version of "Diamonds from Sierra Leone" is largely free-associative and is filled with a litany of lyrical punchlines which serve to loosely chronicle his past experiences being a part of the Roc-A-Fella family, from touring with Jay-Z on his Blueprint Lounge Tour to the label's subsequent fall out and revival.[19] However, West uses the remix to "Diamonds from Sierra Leone" to directly address the issue of "blood diamonds" that people unknowingly wear every day are used to fund horrific civil wars in West Africa.[18] Lyrically, the extensive, uplifting "We Major" is a spiritual exultation of generational and personal success.[48] "Hey Mama" is West's dedication to his mother, Donda West. In the ballad, West recounts past hardships he and his mother suffered through together and expresses his love and devotion for her and appreciation for her tireless support, even when he was going directly against her expectations for him.[11]

In addition, the album includes a series of humorous skits that involve West joining a fictional black fraternity, "Broke Phi Broke," whose members pride themselves in living a life without money or worldly possessions, despite the glaring disadvantages such a lifestyle brings.[49] His character is eventually expelled from the fraternity after their leader discovers that not only has West been making beats for cash on the side but has also been breaking some of its rules, such as eating meals everyday, buying new clothes, and taking showers. According to music writer Mickey Hess, the skits serve to encapsulate, "a contradiction at the core of contemporary American life: the need to belong, to fit in, with your fellow humans versus the Darwinistic mad grab at material things, success in the latter being the very definition of success in our culture."[49] The skits were performed by comedian DeRay Davis, who also voiced the skits on The College Dropout.[50]

Dropout Bear as he appears within the album artwork of Late Registration.

The art direction and music packaging for Late Registration was done by Brooklyn graphic design studio Morning Breath, Inc.[7][51] Similar to its predecessor, the album artwork of the second album carries an educational motif. Where The College Dropout was designed in a manner reminiscent of a high school yearbook, the images contained within the liner notes of Late Registration were taken at Princeton University. West's vision for the style of the pictures was inspired by the works of American satirical painter John Currin, one of his favorite artists.[7] The liner notes also contain a banner that reads Tardus Subcriptio, which is Latin for Late Registration.[7] The album artwork centers around "Dropout Bear", West's anthropomorphic teddy bear mascot, who is dressed in a collegian outfit.[52] Entering Princeton on the front cover, Dropout wanders its hallways, sits in empty lecture halls, and reads multiple library books before departing from the institution the same way he came in on the back cover.[7]

In a preview of Late Registration on April 20, 2005, West appeared on New York radio station Hot 97 and played the lead single "Diamonds from Sierra Leone".[17] The album was originally set to be released on July 12, 2005, but was shifted to August 16 by Roc-A-Fella/Def Jam.[53] It was pushed back once more to August 30 by West himself as he needed more time to complete the album. Late Registration was anticipated to become the biggest-selling record of the year and over 1.6 million copies were distributed to stores in preparation of its first week of release.[54] On the iTunes Store, the album became one of the most pre-ordered titles in the online digital media store's history.[55] West filmed a live album featuring tracks from Late Registration and The College Dropout, titled Late Orchestration which was released April 2006.[56]

A television advertisement for Late Registration was directed and animated by Maggie Rogers, Abby Johnson and Paul Tuersley of Mr & Mrs Smith Design Ltd. It featured a gigantic version of West's teddy bear mascot Dropout Bear roaming through the streets of London. The advert received an award from British music magazine Music Week for Best Music TV Commercial.[57] On the day of the album's release, West made an in-store appearance at New York's Lincoln Center Tower Records to autograph copies for fans.[58] That same day, Late Registration was released in its entirety for online streaming on AOL Music.[59]

In its first week of release, Late Registration debuted at number one on the US Billboard 200 with first week sales of 860,000 copies, selling over 600,000 more copies than Tony Yayo's album Thoughts of a Predicate Felon at number two. This stood as West's first chart-topping album in the United States and gave him nearly double that of The College Dropout's first-week sales.[60] The following week, Late Registration remained atop the chart, though the sales decreased by 67% to 283,000 and the album had sold over 1.14 million copies within its first two weeks on the Billboard 200.[61] Late Registration was certified triple platinum in the US by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) on February 24, 2006 for sales of three million units.[62] The album had the highest-selling first week sales in the US for two years till West's own Graduation sold more in September 2007.[63] As of June 2013, the album has sold 3.1 million copies in the US.[64] The 860,000 copies sold in Late Registration's first week of release ranked as the eighth largest first week sales in hip hop history up to January 7, 2019.[65]

Late Registration also debuted at number one on the Canadian Albums Chart.[66] In the United Kingdom, the album reached number two on the UK Albums Chart for the issue date of September 5, being prevented from topping the chart by McFly's album Wonderland; however, both albums were new entries that week.[67] As of May 2018, Late Registration is the 12th highest-selling rap album in the UK in the 21st century.[68] By November of that year, the album had sold 852,000 copies in the UK, ranking as West's highest selling album in the country.[69] It peaked at number 14 on the ARIA Albums chart in April 2006 and spent 28 weeks on the chart in total.[70][71] Late Registration was the third highest selling album on iTunes in 2005.[72]

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Metacritic	85/100[73]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[74]
Blender	[75]
Entertainment Weekly	B+[76]
The Guardian	[77]
Los Angeles Times	[78]
NME	8/10[15]
Pitchfork	9.5/10[46]
Rolling Stone	[2]
Spin	B+[34]
USA Today	[79]

Late Registration was met with widespread critical acclaim. At Metacritic, which assigns a normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from professional publications, the album received an average score of 85, based on 31 reviews.[73]

Reviewing the album in Rolling Stone, Rob Sheffield deemed it "an undeniable triumph, packed front to back, so expansive it makes the debut sound like a rough draft", while calling West "a real MC."[2] Uncut magazine's Simon Reynolds found most of the songs brilliant and highlighted by what he called an unparalleled use of vocal samples by West,[80] while Josh Tyrangiel from Time said the sampling and string arrangements on "Gone" may persuade listeners to believe West's own hype.[47] In The Guardian, Alexis Petridis praised West's topicality and subversive studio production, writing that "Late Registration suggests an artist effortlessly outstripping his peers: more ideas, better lyrics, bigger hooks, greater depth."[77] Andy Kellman from AllMusic viewed West's rapping on the album as similar to his rapping on The College Dropout, though claimed that "he can be tremendous as a pure writer" and noted the change in West's production style: "Crude beats and drastically tempo-shifted samples are replaced with a more traditionally musical touch from Jon Brion."[74] Kitty Empire of The Observer viewed Late Registration as a significant milestone in hip hop while calling West "the Brian Wilson of hip-hop" because he "plays up the struggle between conscience and covetousness, the pop mainstream and what can be achieved within the notional boundaries of hip hop."[37] Robert Hilburn of the Los Angeles Times compared West's dignified execution of pop crossover on the album to that of The Beatles, Johnny Cash, and Bob Marley.[78] Sean Fennessey from Pitchfork felt West avoided the sophomore slump with an "expansive, imperfect masterpiece" that drew on his enthusiastic, ambitious, and scattered personality.[46] Christgau, writing in The Village Voice, praised the album's "exquisite details", both lyrical and musical, and concluded that West is "as good as he thinks he is ... He wants everybody to buy this record. So do I";[24] he would later assign it an "A+" grade.[81]

Some reviewers were more qualified in their praise. In The A.V. Club, Nathan Rabin found Late Registration as ambitious as The College Dropout but "less successful" because of melodramatic lyrics and "symphonics" without a "strong narrative" to hold the songs together, with him concluding that the album "plays like a brilliant first draft, flawed and uneven, but radiating humor and heart."[82] Jon Pareles believed West's elevated status undermined the underdog quality that had accentuated his debut studio album; he wrote in The New York Times that "for much of Late Registration, the striver has turned into a hip-hop V.I.P., and a cool arrogance has crept into the songs."[43] Hattie Collins of NME was highly impressed by the beats in the music, which she called "pure cranium-crushing boom bap at its best", but lamented the lack of "rubbish lyrics" and clumsy charm that distinguished West's debut album for hardcore fans.[15] In the opinion of Spin magazine's Jon Caramanica, the augmented versatility and eccentricity of West's flow still "pales in comparison to his sonic ambition."[34]

Credits are adapted from the album's liner notes.[7]

Credits are adapted from the album's liner notes.[7]

• 2005 in hip hop music
• Kanye West albums discography
• Kanye West production discography
• Late Orchestration
• List of albums containing a hidden track: W
• List of best-selling albums in the United States of the Nielsen SoundScan era
• List of number-one albums of 2005 (Canada)
• List of UK top-ten albums in 2005
• List of UK R&B Albums Chart number ones of 2005
• List of Billboard 200 number-one albums of 2005
• List of number-one rap albums of 2005 (U.S.)
• List of Billboard number-one R&B albums of 2005

Bibliography

• Brown, Jake (2006). Kanye West in the Studio: Beats Down! Money Up! (2000–2006). Colossus Books. ISBN 0-9767735-6-2.
• Hess, Mickey (2007). Icons of Hip Hop: An Encyclopedia of the Movement, Music, and Culture. Greenwood Publishing Group. ISBN 0-313-33904-X.

• Jenkins, Craig (September 2, 2015). "How Kanye West's 'Late Registration' Turned a College Dropout into a Superstar". Noisey. Retrieved September 5, 2015.

• Late Registration at Acclaimed Music (list of accolades)
• Late Registration at Discogs (list of releases)
• Late Registration (Explicit) (Adobe Flash) at Myspace (streamed copy where licensed)