I Had the Craziest Dream

• 1942 Tony Martin recorded the song with Victor Young and His Orchestra for Decca Records (catalog No.4394A) on July 19, 1942.[4]
• 1943 Vera Lynn - a single release.[5]
• 1953 The Skylarks - their recording was a #28 hit,[6]
• 1956 Helen Forrest - included in the album Miss Helen Forrest – Voice of the Name Bands.[7]
• 1956 Lita Roza - for her album Love Is the Answer.[8]
• 1957 Doris Day included the song on her album Hooray for Hollywood (1958).[9]
• 1957 Perry Como - for his album We Get Letters.
• 1958 Nat King Cole - his recording[10] was eventually included in a compilation album called The Unforgettable Nat Cole Sings The Great Songs! in 1966.[11]
• 1960 - a single by Adam Wade.[12]
• 1961 Frankie Vaughan - included in his album Warm Feeling.[13]
• 1965 Al Hirt released a version on his album, They're Playing Our Song.[14]
• 1965 Doris Day - Doris Day's Sentimental Journey.[15]
• 1967 Astrud Gilberto reached #31 on Billboard's Easy listening survey with her remake.[16]
• 1968 Italian-American singer Sergio Franchi recorded the song on his RCA Victor album I'm a Fool to Want You.[17]
• 1969 Ray Charles recorded the song for his ABC/Tangerine album I'm All Yours, Baby!
• 1980 Frank Sinatra - for Trilogy: Past Present Future
• 1986 Johnny Mathis - for his album The Hollywood Musicals.

The song was featured in the first Hit Kit, the U.S. Army's version of successful radio show Your Hit Parade.[18]