Herbert von Karajan

Karajan family arms, granted in 1792

The Karajans were of Greek Macedonian[4][5][6][7][8][9] ancestry. His great-great-grandfather, Georg Karajan (Geórgios Karajánnis, Greek: Γεώργιος Καραγιάννης), was born in Kozani, in the Ottoman province of Rumelia (now in Greece), leaving for Vienna in 1767, and eventually Chemnitz, Electorate of Saxony.[10]

His last name, like several other Ottoman-era ones, contains the Turkish language prefix 'kara' in reference to someone's dark complexion.

He and his brother participated in the establishment of Saxony's cloth industry, and both were ennobled for their services by Frederick Augustus III on 1 June 1792, thus adding the prefix "von" to the family name. This usage disappeared with the abolition of Austrian nobility after World War I. The surname Karajánnis became Karajan.[11] Although traditional biographers ascribed a Slovak and Serbian or simply a Slavic origin to his mother,[12] Karajan's family from the maternal side, through his grandfather who was born in the village of Mojstrana, Duchy of Carniola (today in Slovenia), was Slovene.[11][12][13] Through this line, Karajan was related to the Austrian composer of Slovene descent Hugo Wolf.[14] Karajan seems to have known some Slovene.[11][12]

Herbert von Karajan's parents, Ernst and Marta (née Kosmač)

Heribert Ritter von Karajan was born in Salzburg, Austria-Hungary, the second son of senior consultant Ernst von Karajan and Marta née Kosmač.[15][16] He was a child prodigy at the piano.[17] From 1916 to 1926, he studied at the Mozarteum in Salzburg with Franz Ledwinka (piano), Franz Zauer (harmony), and Bernhard Paumgartner (composition and chamber music).[18] He was encouraged to concentrate on conducting by Paumgartner, who detected his exceptional promise in that regard. In 1926 Karajan graduated from the conservatory and continued his studies at the Vienna Academy, studying piano with Josef Hofmann (a teacher with the same name as the pianist) and conducting with Alexander Wunderer and Franz Schalk.[19]

Karajan made his conductor debut in Salzburg on 22 January 1929. The performance brought attention of the general manager of the Stadttheater in Ulm, and eventually led to Karajan's first appointment as assistant Kapellmeister of the theater.[15][16] His senior colleague in Ulm was Otto Schulmann. After Schulmann was forced to leave Germany in 1933 with the NSDAP take-over, Karajan was promoted to first Kapellmeister.

In the postwar era Karajan maintained a silence about his Nazi Party membership which gave rise to a number of conflicting stories regarding it. One version asserts that because of the changing political climate and the destabilization of his position, Karajan attempted to join the Nazi Party in Salzburg in April 1933, though his membership was later declared invalid for he somehow failed to follow up the application[16] and that Karajan formally joined the Nazi Party in Aachen in 1935, implying that he was not eager to pursue membership. More recent scholarship clears up this confusion: "[t]he truth is that Karajan actually joined the Nazi Party twice. The first time this happened was on 8 April 1933 in Salzburg. He paid the admission fee, received the membership number 1607525 and moved to Ulm. It is said that this accession was never formally carried out. It is also certain that Karajan rejoined the Nazi Party in Aachen in March 1935, this time receiving the membership number 3430914. After the annexation of Austria, the responsible Reich Treasurer of the Nazi Party discovered Karajan's double membership in Munich and declared the first accession invalid. The second was made retroactive to 1 May 1933."[20] During the entire Nazi era he "never hesitated to open his concerts with the Nazi favorite "Horst-Wessel-Lied". Karajan "always maintained he joined strictly for career reasons."[21] His career could not have proceeded without interruption without his demonstratively lukewarm membership. His enemies referred to him as "SS Colonel von Karajan".[22]

In 1933 Karajan made his conducting debut at the Salzburg Festival with the Walpurgisnacht Scene in Max Reinhardt's production of Faust. In Salzburg in 1934, Karajan led the Vienna Philharmonic for the first time, and from 1934 to 1941, he was engaged to conduct operatic and symphony-orchestra concerts at the Theater Aachen.

Karajan's career was given a significant boost in 1935 when he was appointed Germany's youngest Generalmusikdirektor and performed as a guest conductor in Bucharest, Brussels, Stockholm, Amsterdam and Paris.[23] In 1938 Karajan made his debut with the Berlin Philharmonic. The same year, he made his debut with the Berlin State Opera conducting Fidelio, and then enjoyed a major success at the State Opera with Tristan und Isolde. His performance was hailed by a Berlin critic as Das Wunder Karajan (the Karajan miracle). The critic asserted that Karajan's "success with [Richard] Wagner's demanding work Tristan und Isolde sets himself alongside [Wilhelm] Furtwängler and Victor de Sabata, the greatest opera conductors in Germany at the present time".[18] Receiving a contract with Deutsche Grammophon that same year, Karajan made the first of numerous recordings, conducting the Staatskapelle Berlin in the overture to The Magic Flute.

Herbert von Karajan conducting in 1941

Karajan's career continued to thrive at the beginning of the war. In 1939 the Berlin State Opera appointed Karajan as State Kapellmeister and conductor of symphony concerts by the Prussian State Orchestra.[15] He then became music director of the Staatskapelle Berlin, with which he toured in Rome with extraordinary success.[16] However, in the following year his contract in Aachen was discontinued. His marriage to the partly Jewish Anita Gütermann and the prosecution of his agent Rudolf Vedder also contributed to the temporary professional decline, leaving him few engagements beyond a limited season of concerts with the Staatskapelle.[24]

By 1944, Karajan was, according to his own account, losing favour with the Nazi leadership, but he still conducted concerts in wartime Berlin on 18 February 1945. A short time later, in the closing stages of the war, he and his wife Anita fled Germany for Milan, relocating with the assistance of Victor de Sabata.[16][25]

Karajan's increased prominence from 1933 to 1945 has led to speculation that he joined the Nazi Party solely to advance his music career. Critics such as Jim Svejda[26] have pointed out that other prominent conductors, such as Arturo Toscanini, Otto Klemperer, Erich Kleiber, and Fritz Busch, fled Germany or Italy at the time. Richard Osborne noted that among the many significant conductors who continued to work in Germany throughout the war years—Wilhelm Furtwängler, Carl Schuricht, Karl Böhm, Hans Knappertsbusch, Clemens Krauss and Karl Elmendorff—Karajan was one of the youngest and thus one of the least advanced in his career.[27] Karajan was allowed to conduct various orchestras and was free to travel, even to the Netherlands to conduct the Concertgebouw Orchestra and make recordings there in 1943.[28]

Karajan's denazification tribunal, held in Vienna on 15 March 1946, cleared him of illegal activity during the Nazi period.[24] Karajan was discharged by the Austrian denazification examining board on 18 March 1946, and resumed his conducting career shortly thereafter.[29] Therefore, years later former German Chancellor Helmut Schmidt could say about Karajan's Nazi party membership card: "Karajan was obviously not a Nazi. He was a Mitläufer".[20]

In 1946, Karajan gave his first post-war concert in Vienna with the Vienna Philharmonic, but he was banned from further conducting activities by the Soviet occupation authorities because of his Nazi party membership. That summer he participated anonymously in the Salzburg Festival.

External audio

Karajan conducting Johannes Brahms' A German Requiem with the Vienna Philharmonic, Elisabeth Schwarzkopf and Hans Hotter in 1947

On 28 October 1947, Karajan gave his first public concert following the lifting of the conducting ban. With the Vienna Philharmonic and the Gesellschaft der Musikfreunde, he performed Johannes Brahms' A German Requiem for a gramophone production in Vienna.[30]

In 1949, Karajan became artistic director of the Gesellschaft der Musikfreunde, Vienna. He also conducted at La Scala in Milan. His most prominent activity at this time was recording with the newly formed Philharmonia Orchestra in London, helping to build them into one of the world's finest. Starting from this year, Karajan began his lifelong attendance at the Lucerne Festival.[31]

In 1951 and 1952, he conducted at the Bayreuth Festspielhaus.

During their tour of the United States in 1955, Karajan's past membership in the Nazi Party led to the Berlin Philharmonic's concerts being banned in Detroit, while Philadelphia Orchestra music director Eugene Ormandy refused to shake Karajan's hand. Upon arriving in New York City for a concert at Carnegie Hall, Karajan and the Berlin Philharmonic were confronted by protests and picketers.[32] Reviews of the concert that night were enthusiastic and quietened most of the protesters.

In 1956, Karajan was appointed principal conductor for life of the Berlin Philharmonic as successor to Wilhelm Furtwängler.[33]

From 1957 to 1964, he was artistic director of the Vienna State Opera. Karajan was closely involved with the Vienna Philharmonic and the Salzburg Festival, where he initiated the Easter Festival, which would remain tied to the Berlin Philharmonic's Music Director after his tenure.

Karajan's headstone in the graveyard of the Heiliger Oswald church in Anif, Austria, just outside Salzburg

In his later years, Karajan suffered from heart and back problems, needing surgery on the latter. Karajan resigned as the Principal Conductor of the Berlin Philharmonic on 24 April 1989.[34] His last concert was Bruckner's 7th Symphony with the Vienna Philharmonic. He died of a heart attack at his home in Anif on 16 July 1989 at the age of 81.[2]

Karajan read the works of Father Hugo Enomiya-Lassalle on Zen Buddhism. He became a practitioner of Zen Buddhism. He believed strongly in reincarnation and said that he would like to be reborn as an eagle so he could soar over his beloved Alps.[2] Even so, on 29 June 1985, he conducted Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart's Coronation Mass during a Mass celebrated by John Paul II in St. Peter's Basilica, on the Feast of Sts. Peter and Paul, and received Holy Communion from the hand of the Pope with his wife and daughters.[35] By the end of his life he had reconciled with the Catholic Church, and requested a Catholic burial.[36]

Karajan family in Austria, 1968

On 26 July 1938, Karajan married Elmy Holgerloef, an operetta singer. He first worked with Elmy on a 1935 New Year's Eve gala production of Strauss's Die Fledermaus. They divorced in 1942. Elmy died of heart failure[37] in 1983. A statement from his Salzburg office stated that Karajan was "very shocked, affected, and deeply upset by the news. He had never forgotten her; she had been a part of his life."[38] Karajan did not, however, attend her funeral in Aachen.

On 22 October 1942, at the height of the Second World War, Karajan married his second wife, Anna Maria "Anita" Sauest, born Gütermann. She was the daughter of a well-known manufacturer of yarn for sewing machines. Having had a Jewish grandfather, she was considered a Vierteljüdin (one-quarter Jewish woman). They divorced in 1958.

On 6 October 1958, Karajan remarried. His third wife was Eliette Mouret, a French model born in Mollans-sur-Ouvèze. She had enjoyed a carefree childhood growing up in Provence before being discovered by Christian Dior when she was just 19 years old. This laid the foundation for an international modelling career. Karajan had first met Mouret in 1957, and was deeply taken with her. Their first daughter, Isabel, was born on 25 June 1960. In 1964, their second daughter, Arabel, was born.

After the death of Herbert von Karajan in July 1989, Eliette von Karajan continued her husband's musical legacy. With the founding of the Herbert von Karajan Centre in Vienna, now situated in Salzburg and known as the Eliette and Herbert von Karajan Institute, she created a cultural memorial dedicated to Karajan that has established itself during the years of its existence as an essential part of the local cultural scene. Her numerous projects, focusing particularly on the development of young people, and her engagement as patron of the Salzburg Easter Festival, mean that Eliette von Karajan is ensuring that her husband's work is still heard long after his death, remaining a living thing for generations to come.[39]

Karajan at Schiphol, 1963

Karajan's custom-built Porsche

Herbert von Karajan was a passionate sportsman since he was a teenager: a passionate skier and swimmer, he even followed a daily yoga ritual. At sea, Karajan won several regattas aboard his racing yachts baptised Helisara. He piloted his Learjet, and was also great sailing and car enthusiast, in particular an amateur of Porsche.[40]

Karajan put the same meticulous attention to detail that made him a master of Nibelungen productions into the design of his cars. When he contacted the Porsche special order department in 1974 about a new Type 930, he made it absolutely clear that he wanted a lighter and more sports-oriented version of the standard production vehicle. Karajan dictated that the car should weigh less than one thousand kilograms and its power-to-weight ratio should be well under four kilos per hp—no easy task, given that the standard version was already at 1,140 kilos and 260 hp. The Porsche CEO at the time, Ernst Fuhrmann, carried out the special wishes of his prominent customer himself. Karajan's Turbo was given the racing chassis of an RSR and the body of a Carrera RS, along with a racing suspension and rollover bars. The interior was rigorously stripped down. The backseat was replaced by a steel roll cage, while the radio and any symphonies it might have played gave way to the harmonies of the flat-six engine, which could mobilize around 100 more hp thanks to a larger turbocharger and a sharper camshaft. Lightweight construction even extended to replacing the door handles with slim leather straps that opened the catch when pulled. And Porsche specifically requested permission from Rossi, the vermouth producer, to replicate the Martini racing paint job from the 911 Carrera RSR Turbo 2.1 that finished second in the 24 Hours of Le Mans in 1974. The resulting 1975 unique and tailored 911 Turbo model still carries Karajan's name to this day.[41]

Perhaps the most distinctive feature of Karajan's conducting style was his propensity to conduct with his eyes closed. This was, and is, highly unusual for a conductor to do on anything but occasion, as eye-contact is generally regarded as of paramount importance to the conductor's communication with the orchestra's players. Yet, as Vaughan wryly remarks, "[h]ere is one of the fascinating aspects of conducting: there are no rules, only guidelines. The most eccentric approach is tolerated if the results are successful."[43] And there can be no doubt that Karajan was successful and eccentric. Indeed, James Galway, who served as principal flutist of the Berlin Philharmonic from 1969 to 1975, recalled that "he [Karajan] achieved most of what wanted through charm".[44]

Behind many of Karajan's eccentricities though, was a reason. Conducting with his eyes closed, for instance, was a consequence of memorizing scores—with that out of the way, what need he look at?[43] Karajan's method of score study, too, was somewhat unusual, as was noted by his friend Walter Legge, who remarked that "He [Karajan] is one of the few conductors I have known who has never made a mark in a score. He will absorb a score quietly sitting on the floor, like a relaxed Siamese cat. Over the years he has learned how completely to relax the body so the mind is absolutely free to do what it wants."[45] Karajan was also known to have a preternaturally keen sense of tempo, even going so far as to have himself tested against a computer to prove it. He insisted that this skill was learned, not inherited, and considered it the bedrock of musical interpretations. In fact, he cited inconsistencies in rhythmic accuracy and control as "one thing that might make me lose my temper. I can accept a wrong note from an orchestra but when everything is getting faster or slower, that I cannot accept."[46]

He once explained to a German journalist why he preferred the Berlin to the Vienna Philharmonic. "If I tell the Berliners to step forward, they do it. If I tell the Viennese to step forward, they do it. But then they ask why."[47]

Karajan was a noted interpreter of virtually every standard of the classical repertoire, from the Baroque era through to the twentieth century. He was an admirer of Glenn Gould's interpretations of Bach, even performing the D minor Keyboard Concerto with him on one occasion. The eminent Haydn scholar H. C. Robbins Landon considered Karajan's recordings of the 12 London Symphonies as some of the finest he knew, and his multiple Beethoven cycles are still staples of many a CD collection.[48]

Yet Karajan's real interests seem to have lain in the period from the late-19th to the mid-20th centuries. Principal among these were his fascinations with the composers Anton Bruckner and Jean Sibelius. In an interview with Gramophone's Robert Layton in 1981, Karajan remarked that he felt "a much deeper influence, affinity, kinship – call it what you like – [in Sibelius's music] with Bruckner. There is this sense of the ur-wald, the primaeval forest, the feeling of elemental power, that one is dealing with something profound."[49] When pressed about this connection towards the end of his life by biographer Richard Osborne, Karajan echoed some of these same sentiments, commenting: "There is in both [Bruckner and Sibelius] a sense of the elemental. But I have often asked myself what it is that drew me to Sibelius's music and I think it is that he is a composer who cannot really be compared to anyone else. ... And you never come to an end with him. I think it is perhaps also to do with my love of remote places, my love of mountains rather than cities."[50] Layton demystifies this relationship somewhat by observing that "[s]tring tremolandi and pedal points are, of course, among [the similarities between Bruckner and Sibelius' music], and we hear Brucknerian echoes in the development section of the first movement of Kullervo, written only a year or so after Sibelius first heard Bruckner's Third Symphony in Vienna."[49] Yet the most potent assessment of Karajan's interpretation of Sibelius's music came from Sibelius himself, who, according to record producer Walter Legge, said that "Karajan is the only conductor who plays what I meant."[51]

Karajan was also a prolific opera conductor, championing the works of both Wagner and Verdi, along with the likes of Strauss and Puccini. Verdi's last opera, Falstaff, was something of a mainstay throughout Karajan's career. In his conversations with Richard Osborne, Karajan recalled that, in the 1930s, when Italian opera was still something of a rarity in Austria and Germany, "[m]y training in Verdi's Falstaff came from [Arturo] Toscanini. There wasn't a rehearsal in either Vienna or Salzburg at which I wasn't present. I think I heard about thirty. From Toscanini I learnt the phrasing and the words – always with Italian singers, which was unheard of in Germany then. I don't think I ever opened the score. It was so in my ears, I just knew it."[52] He went on to make two recordings of it – one for EMI in 1956 and another for Philips in 1980 – and his production at the Vienna State Opera was hailed by his colleague Otto Klemperer as "'really excellent.'"[53] Likewise, Richard Strauss was a continual force in Karajan's life, not just as a composer, but as a conductor as well. Karajan regaled their only ‘proper' meeting, in 1939, to Osborne, stating that "at the end [of a performance of Elektra in Berlin] he [Strauss] came and said to me it was the best performance of the opera he had ever heard. I said, 'I don't really want to hear this; tell me what was wrong with it.' I think he was surprised by my reaction, so he asked me to lunch the next day. He said, 'You have made the music very clear, the fp here, the accent there; but these are not at all important. Just wave your stick around a bit!' He made a gesture like stirring a pudding. But what he meant was, let the music flow more naturally."[54]

Karajan conducted and recorded prolifically, mainly with the Berlin Philharmonic and the Vienna Philharmonic. Although he conducted other orchestras (including the NHK Symphony Orchestra, the New York Philharmonic, the Concertgebouw Orchestra, the Orchestre de Paris, the Orchestra of Teatro alla Scala, Milan and the Staatskapelle Dresden), the vast majority of his recordings were made with the Berlin and Vienna orchestras with which he was most associated. He also left a considerable legacy of recordings with the Philharmonia Orchestra, his last performance being in 1960.[55]

Although he made recordings with several labels, notably EMI, it is Deutsche Grammophon with which he became most associated. He made 330 recordings with Deutsche Grammophon during his career.[56] Karajan's 1981 recording of An Alpine Symphony by Deutsche Grammophon conducting the Berlin Philharmonic became the first work ever to be pressed on the compact disc format. Even though his repertoire had been extensively covered in analog (LP record), he spent of the rest of that decade making digital recordings; notably re-recording Ludwig van Beethoven's nine symphonies (Karajan and the Berlin Philharmonic's 1977 analog recording of Beethoven's Symphony No. 3 won the Grand Prix du Disque, while their 1984 digital recording of the same piece was not particularly critically acclaimed yet sold for considerably more). In the early 2000s, Deutsche Grammophon sold the Karajan Masters re-release of Karajan's 1980s digital recordings that had been further enhanced by 24-bit processing.

The so-called ‘Karajan sound' which so distinguished his style as a conductor remains something of a litmus test for critics, dividing them into two competing camps. Two reviews from the Penguin Guide to Compact Discs illustrate this point:

• Concerning a recording of Wagner's Tristan und Isolde (1971–72 studio recording), a canonical Romantic work, the Penguin authors wrote, "Karajan's is a sensual performance of Wagner's masterpiece, caressingly beautiful and with superbly refined playing from the Berlin Philharmonic".[57]
• About Karajan's recording of Haydn's "Paris" symphonies, the same authors wrote, "big-band Haydn with a vengeance ... It goes without saying that the quality of the orchestral playing is superb. However, these are heavy-handed accounts, closer to Imperial Berlin than to Paris ... the Minuets are very slow indeed ... These performances are too charmless and wanting in grace to be whole-heartedly recommended."[58]

The New York Times writer John Rockwell wrote in 1989: "He had a particular gift for Wagner and above all for [Anton] Bruckner, whose music he conducted with sovereign command and elevated feeling."[2]

Despite Karajan's significant prowess as a conductor, he was more often seen behind the camera than in the teaching studio, preferring to record rehearsals rather than give masterclasses. He maintained a long friendship with Seiji Ozawa whose success makes him Karajan's most reputable student.[62] Indeed, Ozawa was reportedly a strong contender to succeed Karajan with the Berlin Philharmonic; Karajan specifically mentioned him as a "conductor with the best character" for the position.[63][59]

Karajan was the recipient of multiple honours and awards. He became a Grand Officer of the Order of Merit of the Italian Republic on 17 May 1960,[64] and in 1961 he received the Austrian Medal for Science and Art. He also received the Grand Merit Cross (Grosses Bundesverdienstkreuz) of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany.

Street sign for Herbert-von-Karajan-Straße outside the Philharmonie in Berlin

In 1977 he was awarded the Ernst von Siemens Music Prize. On 21 June 1978 he received the honorary degree of Doctor of Music from Oxford University.[65] He was honored with Médaille de Vermeil from the Académie française in Paris,[66] the Gold Medal of the Royal Philharmonic Society in London,[67] the Olympia Award of the Onassis Foundation[68] and the UNESCO International Music Prize.[69] He received two Gramophone Awards for recordings of Mahler's Ninth Symphony and the complete Parsifal recordings in 1981. He received the Eduard Rhein Ring of Honor from the German Eduard Rhein Foundation in 1984.[70] He was voted into the inaugural Gramophone Hall of Fame in 2012.[71] He has received the Picasso Medal from UNESCO.

From 2003 to 2015, the Festspielhaus Baden-Baden awarded the annual Herbert von Karajan Music Prize in recognition of excellence in musical achievements.[72] In 2003 Anne-Sophie Mutter, who had made her debut with Karajan in 1977, became the first recipient of this award. Since 2015 the music award has been replaced by the Herbert von Karajan Prize presented at the Salzburg Easter Festival.[73]

Karajan was an honorary citizen of Salzburg (1968), Berlin (1973), and Vienna (1978). His legacy is managed since 2005 by the Eliette and Herbert von Karajan Institute.

Karajan's multiple Grammy Awards make him a particularly prominent conductor historically; his career spanned 40 Grammy nominations across nearly 30 years. Karajan was a three-time Grammy Award recipient, having won Best Opera Recording award for Bizet's Carmen in 1964 and Wagner's Siegfried in 1969, and the Best Classical Orchestral Performance for a Beethoven symphony cycle in 1978.[74] Karajan's Beethoven cycles remain some of the most popular and enduring in record collections worldwide, as well as the most critically acclaimed recordings of the past century.[75][76]

Statue of Karajan in the garden of his birthplace in Salzburg

Even after his death in 1989, Karajan has remained a visible part of everyday-life in the cities he once called home, thanks in part to the monuments that have been erected in his honor. In Salzburg, for instance, the Karajan Foundation of Vienna commissioned the Czech artist Anna Chromý to create of life-sized statue of the conductor which now stands outside his birthplace.[77]

In February 1983, a bronze bust of Karajan was unveiled in the foyer of the newly built State Theatre in Berlin.

Two of Karajan's interpretations were popularized through their inclusion in the soundtrack for the film 2001: A Space Odyssey. Most famously, the version of Johann Strauss' The Blue Danube which is heard during the film's early outer space scenes is that of Karajan conducting the Berlin Philharmonic. Secondly, the version of Richard Strauss' Also Sprach Zarathustra which is used in the film is that of Karajan conducting the Vienna Philharmonic.[78][lower-alpha 1]

Receiving a contract with Deutsche Grammophon in 1938[79] Karajan was notably fastidious for his studious perfectionism when creating hundreds of symphonic recordings, as well as numerous opera recordings by Verdi and Puccini, in particular those with Maria Callas.[80] Highlights of Karajan's recordings with the Berlin Philharmonic include Richard Strauss' Also Sprach Zarathustra, Wagner's Der Ring Des Nibelungen, and Mahler's Symphony No. 5.

During Karajan's lifetime, the public often associated him with the works of Beethoven. Karajan recorded four complete Beethoven symphony cycles,[81] first with the Philharmonia Orchestra for Angel in 1951 to 1955,[82] and then three times with the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra for Deutsche Grammophon in 1961/62,[83] 1975/76,[84] and from 1982 to 1984.[85]

Among 20th-century musical works, Karajan had a preference for conducting and recording works from the first half of the century, by such composers as Mahler, Schoenberg, Berg, Webern, Bartók, Sibelius, Richard Strauss, Puccini, Honegger, Prokofiev, Debussy, Ravel, Hindemith, Nielsen and Stravinsky. Performances of works written post-1950 included Shostakovich's Tenth Symphony, written in 1953, which he performed many times and recorded twice. He and Shostakovich met during a tour with the Berlin Philharmonic culminating in Moscow in May 1969[86] and Karajan had stated in an interview with the German TV-channel ZDF in 1983 that if he had been a composer instead of conductor, his music would have sounded similar to Shostakovich's. Karajan conducted the Berlin Philharmonic in Hans Werner Henze's Sonata per Archi (1958) and Antifone (1960). In 1960 he performed Ildebrando Pizzetti's opera Assassinio nella cattedrale written two years before. Karajan premiered Carl Orff's De temporum fine comoedia in 1973 with the Cologne Radio Symphony Orchestra and recorded the work for Deutsche Grammophon.