Contestants
Name
| Episode Eliminated
| Type
|
Sarah Cooley
| Episode 8 Winner
| Total Liar
|
Sarah Rosselli
| Episode 8 (Runner-Up)
| Full of It
|
Katie Krause
| Episode 8 (2nd Runner-Up)
|
|
Ana Vuletic
| Episode 7 (Quit)
| Frenemy
|
Amber Deylon
| Episode 6
| Hot Mess
|
Reena Hawley
| Episode 5
| Piece of Work
|
Qui Okoroji
| Episode 4
| Pure Evil
|
Vanessa "Marie" Haraskewicz
| Episode 3 (Quit)
| So Fake
|
Jennifer "Julin" Guhlin
| Episode 2
| Backstabber
|
Jillian Hallman
| Episode 1
| Major Diva
|
Episode progress
# | Contestants | Episodes |
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
1 |
Sarah C |
SAFE |
SAFE |
SAFE |
WIN |
BTM 3 |
BTM 2 |
WIN |
WIN |
2 |
Sarah R |
SAFE |
BTM 2 |
SAFE |
SAFE |
SAFE |
SAFE |
BTM 2 |
BURN |
3 |
Katie |
SAFE |
SAFE |
BTM 3 |
BTM 2 |
SAFE |
BTM 3 |
WIN |
BURN |
4 |
Ana |
BTM 2 |
SAFE |
SAFE |
SAFE |
BTM 2 |
WIN |
QUIT |
|
5 |
Amber |
SAFE |
BTM 3 |
SAFE |
BTM 3 |
SAFE |
BURN |
|
6 |
Reena |
BTM 3 |
SAFE |
BTM 3 |
SAFE |
BURN |
|
7 |
Qui |
SAFE |
SAFE |
BTM 3 |
BURN |
|
8 |
Vanessa |
SAFE |
WIN |
QUIT |
|
9 |
Julin |
WIN |
BURN |
|
10 |
Jillain |
BURN |
|
- The contestant won Pretty Wicked.
- The contestant was the Runner-Up
- The contestant won immununity from elimination.
- The contestant won the challenge, but did not receive immunity.
- The contestant was safe from elimination.
- The contestant was in the bottom 3.
- The contestant was in the bottom 2.
- The contestant was eliminated.
- The contestant quit the competition.
- The contestant won immunity, but quit the competition.
- The contestant quit, but then returned for elimination and was in the bottom 3.
- In Episode 3 Katie, Qui and Reena were chosen as the bottom three, but due to Vanessa's withdrawal, there was no bottom two and none of them went home.
- Episodes 7 and 8 were part of the two-hour Season Finale.
Episode review
Episode 1: Mirror Mirror Not On The Wall
- Challenge: Talk to blind guys
- Challenge Winner/Immunity: Julin
- Bottom 3: Reena, Ana, Jillian
- Eliminated: Jillian
Episode 2: Sell Your Soul
- Challenge: Auction off their stuff
- Challenge Winner/Immunity: Team 1 Reena, Qui, and Vanessa but immunity was chosen by Reena and Qui to go to Vanessa.
- Quit: Amber (She returned for elimination)
- Bottom 3: Amber, Sarah R., Julin
- Eliminated: Julin
Episode 3: Slow Roasted
- Challenge: Comedy Roast
- Challenge Winner/Immunity: Vanessa
- Bottom 3: Sarah R., Qui, Reena
- Quit: Vanessa
Episode 4: You're it Girl
- Challenge: Slash Challenge & Interview by Pat O'Brien
- Challenge Winner/Immunity: Sarah C.
- Bottom 3: Katie, Amber, Qui
- Eliminated: Qui
Episode 5: In Frenemy Territory
- Challenge: Fake Rescue Mission
- Challenge Winner no one
- Bottom 3: Ana,Sarah C.,Reena
- Eliminated: Reena
Episode 6: The Truth About Lies
- Challenge: Lie Detector Test
- Challenge Winner: Ana
- Bottom 2: Amber, Sarah C.
- Eliminated: Amber
Episode 7: Who Wins? (Part 1)
- Challenge: Night on the town with aged make-up.
- Challenge Winners: Sarah C., Katie
- Bottom two: Ana & Sarah R.
- Quit: Ana
Episode 8: Who Wins? (Part 2)
- Challenge: Watching audition tape then writing a letter to "old" self
- Second Runner-Up: Katie
- Runner-Up: Sarah R.
- Winner: Sarah C.