Ansfried the Elder, Count in Lotharingia

Ansfried, was a Lotharingian count in the 10th century, who held 15 counties in Lotharingia, a "middle kingdom" which was in this period contested for by the larger eastern and western kingdoms surrounding it. He is sometimes referred to as "the elder" in order to distinguish him from his nephew, Bishop Ansfried of Utrecht, who was also a powerful count until he became a cleric.

Thietmar, describing his nephew of the same name, said that he had two paternal uncles, Ansfried and Robert, Bishop of Trier.[1] This implies that Ansfried the elder is brother to Bishop Robert, who was often described as a relative to the Ottonians, the royal family at the time.[2] It was Thietmar who described Ansfried the elder, the uncle, as a count of 15 counties, and says it was he who sent his nephew to Bruno the great for his education, after he had already spent time with his other uncle.

If Ansfried was the same as the advocatus of the Abbey of Gembloux in the 950s, as is often thought, then he is described as a blood-relative (consanguineus) of Wicfrid, the founder of that Abbey. And if he was the rebel who held Chevremont in 939 after the Battle of Andernach, then he was also described as a nephew of the leader who fell at that battle, Duke Gilbert of Lotharingia.

Records

Records of him have often been proposed though many of them are argument by at least some historians to be someone else, such as his nephew.

Not yet described as a count, a first mention might be in 928, in a grant made by Gilbert, Duke of Lotharingia.[3] Jongbloed suggests this partly because of the presence also of an Arnold, and the fact that in a more certain record, in 939 when a count named Ansfried is described by Widukind of Corvey as one of the leaders of the Lotharingian people, it is also together with an Arnold, possibly his brother. The two of them, described as nepotes (probably nephews) of Gilbert, held the fortification of Chevremont near Liège after the Lotharingians lost the Battle of Andernach in 939, until they were talked down and captured. (Widukind says that Ansfried was partly convinced by an offer of alliance and marriage with the only daughter of Count Immo, with whom he was negotiating. Jongbloed, in the discussion about debate concerning whether Count Immo was Ehrenfrid, son of Ricfrid, suggests that this went ahead. Karsten points out that Widukind clearly wanted to give the impression that the offer was made in bad faith.) Widukind reports that Ansfried being as "hard as iron" would need the harshest torments to question him.[4]

In 950, a count Ansfried "fidelis noster" (our faithful) is described by Louis "d'Outremer", king of West Francia ("France"), which had control of Lotharingia at the time, who had married Gerberga, also present, the former wife of his ally Duke Gilbert of Lotharingia after his death at Andernach. Because this count is a vassal of the western king, there are doubts about whether it could be Ansfried, whose homeland of Lotharingia was by this time back under control of the eastern kingdom ("Germany"). However Jongbloed (2009 p.32) argues that during this period the western kingdom was a defeated "quasi protectorate", and so being a double vassal would be possible.

Soon after, in a charter of 7 Oct 950, Kessel on the left bank of the Maas between Roermond and Venlo is described as being "in pago Masalant in comitatu Ruodolfi" (in the country of Maasland, in the county of Rudolf), and "cuidam vassallo nostro Ansfrid" (a certain vassal of ours Ansfried) is the beneficiary of rights there.[5] This Count Rudolf appears to have been the brother of Reginar III, and also a count in the Hesbaye region who would have his lands confiscated, probably around 953 when his brother was exiled.

...From this time on, there is disagreement about whether there are any more sightings of the elder Ansfried in the records...

According to some historians such as Aarts, he is mentioned by Sigebert of Gembloux as the advocate (vogt) of the newly founded Gembloux Abbey in the 950s, the reign of Bishop Balderic II in Liège.[6] Historians who believe this argue that the younger Ansfried would have been too young. Van Winter on the other hand has argued that this record is incorrectly dated, and that these events in Gembloux must have been in the 980s when young Ansfried returned from Italy. There is therefore a similar debate about whether the elder Ansfried is also the son named Ansfried who observed in a transaction described by Sigebert, who served as a witness to a transaction between a noble named Lambert and the founder of Abbey, acting on its behalf, Wicbert (also written Guibert etc). (This Ansfried is often suggested to be the younger nephew, and there is also debate about whether this Ansfried was in any case son of Lambert or Wicbert.) Nevertheless, all of these people are likely to be related to each other and presumably to share descent from Wicbert's grandparents Gisla and Rothing.[7]

When Otto I returned from Italy in early 965, historians such as Aarts think that the Ansfrid who appears in a high position in a list from Liège must be him, and not his nephew who was still young, and who may indeed still have been in Italy.[8]

Later in the 960s are two records of a Count Ansfried with a county in or near the Dutch river delta area, one in Varik in Teisterbant, and one in Toxandria.[9] There is also one more charter which connects an Ansfried to the wife of his late Duke Gilbert, in 968, when he was involved in a charter concerning her allodial rights in the area of Meerssen in the Maasland.[10]

In July 985, one of the Ansfrieds, comes illustris vir, was granted the County of Huy, near Liège.[11]

Notable non-consensus speculations

There are two very notable proposals which have created a lasting consensus, but which are widespread in secondary literature.

1. Vanderkindere (1902), proposed that Ansfried was in fact the same person as Ehrenfrid, son of Ricfrid, and that an otherwise unattested sister of this Ehrenfried married the above-mentioned Lambert, the so-called Count of Louvain. The elder Ansfried, in this explanation, would actually be Bishop Ansfried's maternal uncle, normally avunculus in Latin. This is no longer widely accepted.[12]

2. Jongbloed (2009), proposed that Ansfried the elder married a daughter of Ehrenfried, based mainly on the story of Widukind mentioned above. He furthermore proposed that this Ansfried was, like his nephew with the same name, a founder of the Abbey of Thorn, though the two have later, according to him, become confused.[13]

References

  1. ↑ The Latin word patruus is used, which is normally used to mean paternal uncle.
  2. ↑ Alberic of Trois Fontaines wrote that Robert was even a brother of Queen Mathilda, wife of King Henry I of Germany and mother of Bruno the Great. MGH SS XXIII, anno 921, p.756
  3. ↑ Beyer no.167
  4. ↑ Bachrach p.87
  5. ↑ MGH DD Otto I p.210
  6. ↑ p.529. Baerten (p.1156) thinks this might show signs of a connection to that Bishop.
  7. ↑ Jongbloed 2009 argued that the witness was the younger Ansfried, but a son of Wicbert. This has not been widely accepted. See Aarts and Karsten.
  8. ↑ See Les annales de Flodoard p.157 n2
  9. ↑ MGH DD OI pp.507-8 and MGH SS XXI, p.393
  10. ↑ Oorkonden van Noord-Brabant 690-1312 p.31ff
  11. ↑ MGH DD OIII p.413
  12. ↑ See Baerten and van Winter.
  13. ↑ See Aarts (2016) and Karsten.

Sources

  • Aarts, Bas (1994) "Ansfried, graaf en bisschop. Een stand van zaken", in: J. Coolen en J. Forschelen (ed.), Opera Omnia II. Een verzameling geschied- en heemkundige opstellen , 7-85
  • Aarts, Bas (2009) "Montferland' en de consequenties. De vroege burchten bij Alpertus van Metz", H.L. Janssen en W. Landewé (ed.), Middeleeuwse Kastelen in veelvoud. Nieuwe Studies over oud erfgoed (Wetenschappelijke Reeks Nederlandse Kastelenstichting 2) pp.13-59. link
  • Aarts, Bas (2016) "Het 'eeuwige Strijen'. Speurtocht naar de gravin, haar schenking en haar familie" in Van den Eynde & Toorians (eds) Op zand, veen en klei: Liber amicorum Karel Leenders bij gelegenheid van zijn zeventigste verjaardag, Hilversum, Verloren
  • Bachrach, Berhard S., and Bachrach, David S., (Translators and Editors), Widukind of Corvey’s Deeds of the Saxons, Catholic University Press, Washington, DC, 2014
  • Baerten (1961) "Les Ansfrid au Xe siècle" Revue belge de Philologie et d'Histoire 39-4 pp. 1144-1158
  • Jongbloed, Hein H., (2006) , "Immed “von Kleve” (um 950) – Das erste Klevische Grafenhaus (ca. 885-ca. 1015) als Vorstufe des geldrischen Fürstentums", Annalen des Historischen Vereins für den Niederrhein, Heft 209
  • Jongbloed, Hein H., (2009) "Listige Immo en Herswind. Een politieke wildebras in het Maasdal (938-960) en zijn in Thorn rustende dochter", Jaarboek. Limburgs Geschied- en Oudheidkundig Genootschap vol. 145 (2009) pp.9-67
  • Karsten, (2016) Zwischen Glaube und Welt pp.31-36
  • Vanderkindere, Léon, La Formation territoriale des principautés belges au Moyen Âge, Bruxelles, H. Lamertin, 1902
  • van Winter, (1981) Ansfried en Dirk, twee namen uit de Nederlandse geschiedenis van de 10e en 11e eeuw link

Primary sources

This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.