S. Irfan Habib

The book was subject to mixed receptions. A review over The American Historical Review deemed it to be a carelessly edited book with shoddy introductions and unresolved dissonance across the participating authors.[4] A review over Technology and Culture noted it to be an exciting and enriching volume.[5] A review over Indian Economic and Social History Review disagreed with the excessive put down of Bernalism and other aspects but went on to note it as a very important volume in affirmation of the enduring relevance of Joseph Needham's thought school.[6][7]

The book contained a collection of essays from various journals and prominent publications that focused on how the first generation of scientists in post-Reneissance India responded to and appropriated the theories and practices of modern science into their cultural traditions, often conflicting among themselves but yet working towards a common goal of achieving freedom from colonialism.[8] A review over Social Scientist was positive and noted the work to be an impressive collection of informative and conceptually agile essays from a multitude of disciplines.[8]

Syed's work on Bhagat Singh and his comrades focuses on the range of ideological processes which led to Bhagat Singh's thought-school of revolutionary philosophy and corresponding political manifesto.

K.N. Panikkar, in his review of the book, praised the meticulous documentation and scholarly analysis in the work.[9]

A collection of twelve essays on the topic of colonialism and science in India, it was intended to serve as a general introduction to a reader.[10] Critical reception was mixed.

A review over Cultural and Social History noted the work to provide an useful overview but criticized multiple aspects; many of the essays ran along parallel themes with non-optimal selections, there was an acute lack of intersection with social history contra the stated purpose of the book and that the language was often too sophisticated and abstract, for the intended audience.[10] A review over the Indian Journal of History of Science was scathing; it noted the sole endeavor of the book to demonstrate western efficiency and Indian deficiency in the progress of science.[11]

A review over Current Science praised multiple aspects of the volume and went on to note it as a valuable and impressive addition to the field esp. to potential students.[12] A review over Journal of Social History admired the multitude of viewpoints in the collection of essays and noted it to be an indispensable contribution to the field.[13] A review over Indian Historical Review noted all the selected essays to be products of insightful analyses and that the work will serve as a valuable introduction to graduate students in the domain.[14] A review over Contributions to Indian Sociology noted it to be an useful work, as well.[15]

The Hindu reviewed it as a timely scholarship which shone a spotlight on longstanding scientific discourses and rational thought schools in Islam.[16]Author and literary critic Us Salam Ziya deemed it to be a brilliant work with insightful scholarly arguments.[17]

The book was subject to widespread positive reception. Irfan Habib noted it to be a comprehensive but careful selection of writings that represented all the major ideological schools of the National Movement; Irfan's introduction and biographical sketches were especially admired.[18] A review over Kitaab.org noted it's immense topical relevance at a time, when a muscular, hyper-patriotic and jingoistic band of nationalism is being increasingly thrust upon the citizens and noted Irfan to have perfected the near-impossible task of summarizing a diverse set of pluralistic ideas, with appropriate commentary.[19] Syed expressed similar motivations, upon the launch of the book.[2] C P Bhambri, former dean of the School of Social Sciences, JNU noted the book to provide a plethora of insights about the idea of nationalism in India and deemed it to be a necessary read in light of the current climate.[20]

Consisting of a selected collection of Bhagat Singh's writings, the work located them in the context of contemporary nationalism.[21] Irfan Habib noted it to be a thoughtful collection and deemed Syed's introduction to be insightful, which identified the core elements of Bhagat Singh's ideology in a clear manner.[18] C P Bhambri, former dean of the School of Social Sciences, JNU noted the volume to have done yeoman's service in correcting stereotyped notions about Singh's philosophy and in showing the need for widespread assimilation of his thought school instead of the token gratitude, bestowed on Singh, as a revolutionary martyr.[22]