Paula Barbieri

Barbieri first gained public recognition as a fashion model for Vogue and Victoria's Secret. Moreover, Barbieri acted in several low-budget straight-to-video movies in the early to mid 1990s and appeared as a pool hustler in the Double or Nothing (1992) episode of the erotic drama series Red Shoe Diaries with Ely Pouget, Francesco Quinn, and Lisa Boyle. In 1995, she appeared in The Misery Brothers, in The Watcher episode "The Human Condition", and in The Dangerous.[1][2] She also appeared in the Red Shoe Diaries 5: Weekend Pass.[3]^:561 Her last role was as Beverly Hills psychiatrist Dr. Angela Cross in the TV movie Night Eyes 4: Fatal Passion.[4][3]^:582 She posed for a nude pictorial in the October 1994 issue of Playboy and was "the girl" in Michael Bolton's music video for "Completely".

Barbieri had dated O. J. Simpson and was reportedly his last girlfriend before the murder of his ex-wife Nicole Brown Simpson and Brown's friend Ronald Goldman, on June 12, 1994. Barbieri last saw Simpson the night before the murders, when they attended a fundraiser together. On the morning of the murders, Barbieri left Simpson a 30-minute-long message on his answering machine, breaking off their relationship.[5] She indicated she was flying to Las Vegas to be with singer Michael Bolton.[6] Simpson denied ever receiving the message, and his attorney Johnnie Cochran portrayed Simpson and Barbieri as a happy couple. Barbieri was called to testify at Simpson's trial.

Barbieri stuck by Simpson until around November 1995, when it was reported she left after he berated her for the way she dressed and accused her of sleeping around.[7] New York Magazine claimed Barbieri had dumped Simpson for going off with another woman.[8] In an interview that same month, Barbieri claimed she ended their relationship shortly after his acquittal, and he was using her to make money from photographs.[9] She still, however, maintained Simpson was innocent.[9]

In September 1997, Barbieri released the book, The Other Woman: My Years With O.J. Simpson, in which she wrote about becoming a born-again Christian. She claimed their break-up was due to his inability to remain faithful, but asserted he was never physically abusive.[10] In an interview on Larry King Live that same year, she said, "Rather than replace O.J. for my father, I replaced him for God." She also stated: "I'm choosing not to look further into making a decision one way or another" about Simpson's guilt or innocence.[5]

In April 2000, Barbieri married Michael Overstreet, a judge in the 14th Judicial Circuit Court of Florida. They lived in the Panama City, Florida area as of January 2012 and have two daughters (one from Overstreet's first marriage).[11]