Claas Relotius

As a freelance reporter, Relotius wrote for a number of German-language publications, including Cicero, Frankfurter Allgemeine Sonntagszeitung, Neue Zürcher Zeitung, Financial Times Deutschland, Die Tageszeitung, Die Welt, Süddeutsche Zeitung Magazin, Die Weltwoche, Zeit Online and Reportagen.[5]

In 2017, he became a staff journalist for Der Spiegel, which has published almost 60 articles by Relotius since 2011.[6][7] For his detailed reporting, Relotius received several awards, including the Deutscher Reporterpreis on four occasions and as recent as 2018.[4] Relotius' Reporterpreis 2018 award was for "Best Reportage", delivered in Berlin in early December,[8][9][10] for a story of "unprecedented lightness, density and relevance, which never leaves open the sources on which it is based."[11] He was the German language CNN "Journalist of the Year" in 2014 for a story written for the Swiss magazine Reportagen,[5] [12] and won the European Press Prize in 2017.[13] Reporting for which he was nominated or won prizes include articles about Iraqi children kidnapped by the Islamic State, a Guantánamo Bay inmate, and Syrian orphans from Aleppo who ended up as child slaves in Turkey.[14] In 2017, Der Spiegel sent Relotius for three weeks to Fergus Falls, Minnesota, to write an article about Donald Trump supporters "to give readers better insight into Americans."[15] These articles were all found to contain falsifications.[16] Relotius had also faked interviews with the parents of NFL footballer Colin Kaepernick.[17]

On 19 December 2018, Der Spiegel made public that Relotius had admitted that he had "falsified his articles on a grand scale", inventing facts, persons and quotations in at least 14 of his stories in Der Spiegel[6][7], an event now being referred to as "Spiegelgate".[18] The magazine uncovered the fraud after a co-author of one of Relotius's articles about a pro-Trump vigilante group in Arizona conducting patrols along the Mexico–United States border, the Spanish-born Der Spiegel journalist Juan Moreno, became suspicious of the veracity of Relotius's contributions and gathered evidence against him.[6][19][20] About a year earlier, two residents of Fergus Falls, Minnesota, Michele Anderson and Jake Krohn, suspected that Relotius' portrayal of their hometown was inaccurate.[16] For example, Relotius lied about seeing a hand-painted welcome sign by the city limits that read: "Mexicans Keep Out".[17] They investigated on their own when efforts to contact Der Spiegel on Twitter came to nothing.[21] They published their findings in a blog post on Medium, in which they detailed 11 of Relotius' most egregious falsehoods.[22] As Anderson put it, "In 7,300 words he really only got our town’s population and average annual temperature correct".[16]

Relotius' superiors initially supported him after he said the allegations made against him were false.[23] They even suspected that Moreno was slandering him. However, in the face of mounting evidence of Relotius' deceit, Özlem Gezer, the deputy head of the magazine's "Gesellschaft" (society) section and Relotius' immediate supervisor, confronted Relotius and told him she no longer believed him. The following day, Relotius confessed, and Der Spiegel forced his resignation, calling him "neither a reporter nor a journalist".[4] Relotius told his former colleagues that he was sick and needed to get help. Der Spiegel left his articles accessible for the time being, with a notice referring to the magazine's ongoing investigation into the fraud.[7] In the wake of the scandal, Relotius returned four awards he received from Deutscher Reporterpreis, and CNN revoked his 2014 Journalist of the Year award.[2] The awarded article on an Alzheimer patient in a California prison was marked by the Reportagen magazine as under investigation.[24] The issue of Der Spiegel published on 21 December covered the Relotius case over 23 pages with a plain orange cover.[25][26]

Richard Grenell, the US ambassador to Germany, wrote to the magazine complaining about an anti-American institutional bias ("Anti-Amerikanismus") and asked for an independent investigation.[26][27] Grenell wrote that "These fake news stories largely focus on U.S. policies and certain segments of the American people."[28] The American journalist James Kirchick accused Der Spiegel of long peddling "crude and sensational anti-Americanism".[29]

The scandal was seized upon by critics of the mainstream media in Western countries, and was described as a moment of crisis for German journalism. Leaders of the German party Alternative for Germany (AfD) wrote that it confirmed their view of the media as a "lying press" (Lügenpresse).[30]

On 23 December 2018, Der Spiegel magazine announced that it was filing a criminal complaint against Relotius.[31] Relotius has been accused of embezzling donations intended for Syrian orphans he claimed to have met in Turkey. Relotius appealed to readers for donations to be paid into his personal bank account.[32]

• Confirmation bias
• Media bias – Bias or perceived bias of journalists and news producers within the mass media in the selection of events and stories that are reported and how they are covered
• Fake news – Hoax or deliberate spread of misinformation
• Journalistic scandal
• Jayson Blair
• Stephen Glass